Stefano Utoikamanu #241

I would say it is a certainty that his manager leaked it trying to start a bidding war
The real damage gets done when it's announced he is going to Easts or Melbourne for a lesser deal. It never is, of course, particularly at the Roosters, but it reinforces the narrative that an in-demand player will go to a "better" club for less. The News Corp media have a field day with it.
 
The real damage gets done when it's announced he is going to Easts or Melbourne for a lesser deal. It never is, of course, particularly at the Roosters, but it reinforces the narrative that an in-demand player will go to a "better" club for less. The News Corp media have a field day with it.
thats why the salary cap needs an overhaul. clubs shouldnt be able to sign players for less then their market value. they get the player and a bonus to their cap
 
thats why the salary cap needs an overhaul. clubs shouldnt be able to sign players for less then their market value. they get the player and a bonus to their cap
Exactly right.
If there's an 800k contract available that should be what the purchasing club is responsible for.
No more of this "He came to us for unders" rubbish.
 
All the off field perks even Anasta spoke about it the other week on NRL 360 and he is still getting the benefits from being there
Watching the Roosters young middles last week I don’t know why they would be bothered about Stefano
Plenty of talent there already in their forwards it’s their backs they will be spending on.
 
Exactly right.
If there's an 800k contract available that should be what the purchasing club is responsible for.
No more of this "He came to us for unders" rubbish.
It’s not that simple. It needs to be a mean value. You can’t have 1 club just offer above the odds to raise his value. I’d argue 800 is above his market value. This is almost similar to the Jack Wighton situation last year where Canberra offered him an offical 1m deal to ensure his market value is based off that. Don’t think it worked though as Souths paid what they paid and he certainly isn’t standing out as a 1mil player.
And neither is the Ute standing out as a $800k player.

With the Ute set to receive an option extension of between 600 and 700k for next year. This deal is instantly more attractive as there is almost 200k on top of what his option extension was for 25 and it’s almost pointless as to whether he gets picked for origin and or the Tigers make the finals.

This play by Richo is very take it or leave it. Agree to a large extension when it’s on the table or move on. As they stated, they are very keen to get it done sooner then later.
 
It’s not that simple. It needs to be a mean value. You can’t have 1 club just offer above the odds to raise his value. I’d argue 800 is above his market value. This is almost similar to the Jack Wighton situation last year where Canberra offered him an offical 1m deal to ensure his market value is based off that. Don’t think it worked though as Souths paid what they paid and he certainly isn’t standing out as a 1mil player.
And neither is the Ute standing out as a $800k player.

With the Ute set to receive an option extension of between 600 and 700k for next year. This deal is instantly more attractive as there is almost 200k on top of what his option extension was for 25 and it’s almost pointless as to whether he gets picked for origin and or the Tigers make the finals.

This play by Richo is very take it or leave it. Agree to a large extension when it’s on the table or move on. As they stated, they are very keen to get it done sooner then later.
I understand what you are saying and i would agree except for one thing. They only use 1 metric to distribute a very shallow pool of talent across 17 clubs. Until there is another, or a generic system for all clubs to quantify the value of every player in the competition so a player doesn't need to go to market to find their market value. The only solution to stop clubs being able to pay under MV is enforce the MV with in the salary cap.

You mention Jack Whiton. I will raise you Latrell, Teddy, Munster, moses etc etc all players that knocked back 10s to 100s of thousands to not play at the tigers. Were all these players worth the offer at the time probably not. But that doesn't change that the salary cap was made a mockery of.
 
Back
Top