Where does Jason Taylor go with our great hooker policy now?!

[trafford10]

Ok, and what damage is that? A coach can't work with a team if the kingpin (in his own mind) shows no respect for him. Maybe he feels more damage is being caused with Farah still in the picture. I don't know, but the players - no after which ones can not run the show. That's a recipe for failure.

Surely this means Robbie will not be back in the NRL team for the rest of the season?

 

[supercoach]

Nobody can convince me that we are better served playing Deano and Edwards as our no9s. What team plays a no9 without a kicking game.

So All the spin in the world will not change my mind, this either a desperate attempt to get Farah out the door or a really bad personality clash…or both

 

[Grandma]

3 games away from his 250th…. Is this being deliberately mean and spiteful? Not very team like is it? So if a team is picked on form, how do you go from state hooker to reserve grade in one week. Very poor form.

 

[happy_tiger]

Nobody can convince me that we are better served playing Deano and Edwards as our no9s. What team plays a no9 without a kicking game.

So All the spin in the world will not change my mind, this either a desperate attempt to get Farah out the door or a really bad personality clash…or both

Its to try and keep Elijah Taylor SC

Simple as that , Farah stays ,Elijah Taylor goes , we don't have the money for both

And yet we have people still arguing that Robbie must stay

Hasn't anyone watched our team since ET arrival and the massive improvement in our middle third defence alone ?? :brick: :brick: :brick:

 

[Doc_Tiger]

Nobody can convince me that we are better served playing Deano and Edwards as our no9s. What team plays a no9 without a kicking game.

So All the spin in the world will not change my mind, this either a desperate attempt to get Farah out the door or a really bad personality clash…or both

Its to try and keep Elijah Taylor SC

Simple as that , Farah stays ,Elijah Taylor goes , we don't have the money for both

And yet we have people still arguing that Robbie must stay

Hasn't anyone watched our team since ET arrival and the massive improvement in our middle third defence alone ?? :brick: :brick: :brick:

Isn't it the case though, that we only are in front financially if he goes to the dragons?

 

[gallagher]

3 games away from his 250th…. Is this being deliberately mean and spiteful? Not very team like is it? So if a team is picked on form, how do you go from state hooker to reserve grade in one week. Very poor form.

You start with a crap state selection panel.

 

[Geo]

Nobody can convince me that we are better served playing Deano and Edwards as our no9s. What team plays a no9 without a kicking game.

So All the spin in the world will not change my mind, this either a desperate attempt to get Farah out the door or a really bad personality clash…or both

Its to try and keep Elijah Taylor SC

Simple as that , Farah stays ,Elijah Taylor goes , we don't have the money for both

And yet we have people still arguing that Robbie must stay

Hasn't anyone watched our team since ET arrival and the massive improvement in our middle third defence alone ?? :brick: :brick: :brick:

That's not entirely true…Taylor can be retained even with Farah...it may cost us an outside back signing though..

I did find it interesting getting back and watching the State Cup games ...Edwards at hooker caught my eye...thought it may have been due to injuries in State Cup but now makes sense...

 

[stevetiger]

Nobody can convince me that we are better served playing Deano and Edwards as our no9s. What team plays a no9 without a kicking game.

So All the spin in the world will not change my mind, this either a desperate attempt to get Farah out the door or a really bad personality clash…or both

Its to try and keep Elijah Taylor SC

Simple as that , Farah stays ,Elijah Taylor goes , we don't have the money for both

And yet we have people still arguing that Robbie must stay

Hasn't anyone watched our team since ET arrival and the massive improvement in our middle third defence alone ?? :brick: :brick: :brick:

Happy you cannot know this for a fact. It's just that simple.

Another point I'd make is that this club has to act with integrity. If this is all a powerplay to sack Robbie it's pretty poor form.

How would you feel if we did the same thing to Tedesco when he inevitably slows down.

 

[gallagher]

Nobody can convince me that we are better served playing Deano and Edwards as our no9s. What team plays a no9 without a kicking game.

So All the spin in the world will not change my mind, this either a desperate attempt to get Farah out the door or a really bad personality clash…or both

Its to try and keep Elijah Taylor SC

Simple as that , Farah stays ,Elijah Taylor goes , we don't have the money for both

And yet we have people still arguing that Robbie must stay

Hasn't anyone watched our team since ET arrival and the massive improvement in our middle third defence alone ?? :brick: :brick: :brick:

That's not entirely true…Taylor can be retained even with Farah...it may cost us **an outside back signing** though..

I did find it interesting getting back and watching the State Cup games ...Edwards at hooker caught my eye...thought it may have been due to injuries in State Cup but now makes sense...

Anyone in particular you referring to ?

 

[Geo]

Interest in Curtis Rona if the Dogs sign Brenko Lee and Tautau Moga from the Cows..

 

[tigertye]

Interest in Curtis Rona if the Dogs sign Brenko Lee and Tautau Moga from the Cows..

Rona is expected to go to union. Shame really, he's a very underrated player.

 

[Eddie]

Well this "resting" during Origin rubbish can be put to one side,

This powerplay like many have said has been coming for weeks.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Well this "resting" during Origin rubbish can be put to one side,

This powerplay like many have said has been coming for weeks.

I hope that's true because it would mean it hasn't affected the players who still have continued to put in.

 

[Eddie]

Roosters game we were poor I thought.

Be interesting to see how they go this week. I was thinking a big win on Tuesday. Now im not so sure.

 

[Eddie]

so we cant play Liddle?

Cherrington is out of favour.

Ballin is injured.

And were going to play Edwards as back up hooker with Halatau.

Meanwhile Farah is in reserve grade.

You know it makes perfect sense

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Roosters game we were poor I thought.

Be interesting to see how they go this week. I was thinking a big win on Tuesday. Now im not so sure.

You couldn't accuse the players of not having a go.

 

[Eddie]

Mate, the pro Taylor fans like yourself have got what you wanted.

Farah's gone, coach has made his power play.

How the team responds will be the making or breaking of the coach.

We need to win more then we lose in the run in.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Mate, the pro Taylor fans like yourself have got what you wanted.

Farah's gone, coach has made his power play.

How the team responds will be the making or breaking of the coach.

We need to win more then we lose in the run in.

I haven't got what i wanted at all, don't assume.

I have massive concerns about the ripple affect this could have on the other players. I have no problem with the decision, the timing of it though is horrible.

 

[Eddie]

Sorry I have not had time to read the 1 Million posts.

The timing is horrible, for the second year running.

I have the same concerns as you.

I worry about the morale.

However the proof will be in the pudding. If they win 5 straight well ill call him a genius. Lose and well, it could be the rant of the century

 

[happy_tiger]

Nobody can convince me that we are better served playing Deano and Edwards as our no9s. What team plays a no9 without a kicking game.

So All the spin in the world will not change my mind, this either a desperate attempt to get Farah out the door or a really bad personality clash…or both

Its to try and keep Elijah Taylor SC

Simple as that , Farah stays ,Elijah Taylor goes , we don't have the money for both

And yet we have people still arguing that Robbie must stay

Hasn't anyone watched our team since ET arrival and the massive improvement in our middle third defence alone ?? :brick: :brick: :brick:

Isn't it the case though, that we only are in front financially if he goes to the dragons?

As long as whatever club is prepared to take around 350 k of Robbie's contract we will be fine