Would you drop BJ?

[hodgo]

Packer has been.hammered on this forum and he has played some really good games for WTs. JL has been at WTs for a short time and come up with the shocker against the Knights and now this disgrace. I cannot understand how so many believe this is acceptable or in anyway is playing tough football.

We should not forget he also hogged the ball when a try was on offer.

Packer has less impact in the time he has been here then Joey has had in what 5 games

Please, what you have written us utter nonsense,

i understand that you dont like joey its evident. but what has packer actually done for the club. he has been an average forward.
so to show you my utter nonsense lets look at some stats.

in his 3 years here he has played a total of 26 games out of 75
in those games he has averaged 70 run meters per game which is horrible for a starting front rower.
he has made roughly 700 tackle missing 70. so missing 10% of his tackles which isnt bad so maybe a tick for him

That for me tells me he has been a horrible signing right up their with grub.

 

[Goldust]

Not gonnna lie if my brother copped an obvious swinging arm,I’d probably do the same thing.
The panthers without kikua lose that game.
Two soft tries we gave away really didn’t show how good we played.

Without Kikau!!
He did nothing, did you watch the game?
He had 4 touches all night

Did you see the first play of the game?
We had three people marking him every time the panthers went to that side.

 

[Tigers_Tigers]

I wouldnt drop him when comes back from suspension literally because we have no other centres or wingers since jennings is injured. But even so he brings a lot in attack and the aggression is what we need, just needs to learn to calm down.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Packer has been.hammered on this forum and he has played some really good games for WTs. JL has been at WTs for a short time and come up with the shocker against the Knights and now this disgrace. I cannot understand how so many believe this is acceptable or in anyway is playing tough football.

We should not forget he also hogged the ball when a try was on offer.

Packer has less impact in the time he has been here then Joey has had in what 5 games

Please, what you have written us utter nonsense,

i understand that you dont like joey its evident. but what has packer actually done for the club. he has been an average forward.
so to show you my utter nonsense lets look at some stats.

in his 3 years here he has played a total of 26 games out of 75
in those games he has averaged 70 run meters per game which is horrible for a starting front rower.
he has made roughly 700 tackle missing 70. so missing 10% of his tackles which isnt bad so maybe a tick for him

That for me tells me he has been a horrible signing right up their with grub.

Why must I not like JL to hold the view that what he did last night was unacceptable? It has overshadowed the tremendous effort of our team to the point that it lead the sporting news on 9. His actions are clearly inconsistent with what the club is trying to build and has brought very negative coverage to WTs. After all the good press we receive from Harry Grant, this predictable behaviour is so boorish and moronic. Time to move on from JL and play Talau in the centre.

 

[innsaneink]

Packer has been.hammered on this forum and he has played some really good games for WTs. JL has been at WTs for a short time and come up with the shocker against the Knights and now this disgrace. I cannot understand how so many believe this is acceptable or in anyway is playing tough football.

We should not forget he also hogged the ball when a try was on offer.

Packer has less impact in the time he has been here then Joey has had in what 5 games

Please, what you have written us utter nonsense,

i understand that you dont like joey its evident. but what has packer actually done for the club. he has been an average forward.
so to show you my utter nonsense lets look at some stats.

in his 3 years here he has played a total of 26 games out of 75
in those games he has averaged 70 run meters per game which is horrible for a starting front rower.
he has made roughly 700 tackle missing 70. so missing 10% of his tackles which isnt bad so maybe a tick for him

That for me tells me he has been a horrible signing right up their with grub.

Why must I not like JL to hold the view that what he did last night was unacceptable? It has overshadowed the tremendous effort of our team to the point that it lead the sporting news on 9. His actions are clearly inconsistent with what the club is trying to build and has brought very negative coverage to WTs. After all the good press we receive from Harry Grant, this predictable behaviour is so boorish and moronic. Time to move on from JL and play Talau in the centre.

Oh please.... It was a few seconds on 9.... It will be forgotten tomorrow

 

[weststigers]

My issue with all this is that we are going to pay for it for much longer than the 10 minutes he was sin binned.

This stupidity will now cost us for the next 1-4 weeks depending on his suspension. A dumb play with no upside for the team.

16 players busted their gut to get us in a position to win and he throws it all away with that behaviour. We are primed to get knocked off by the Broncos...

 

[hodgo]

yeah stuff buying dynamic players lets just stick to 9th

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

He had a massive brain explosion, its obvious when family is involved he cant keep it together. Putting aside his coat hanger if he can control that aggression no you dont drop him, but the NRL is going to drop him for us anyway they'll throw the book at him 6-8 because the NRL has their agenda against us. Is he the best centre in the game of course not but let him think that anyway its called confidence.

 

[weststigers]

My issue with all this is that we are going to pay for it for much longer than the 10 minutes he was sin binned.

This stupidity will now cost us for the next 1-4 weeks depending on his suspension. A dumb play with no upside for the team.

16 players busted their gut to get us in a position to win and he throws it all away with that behaviour. We are primed to get knocked off by the Broncos...

So, you've given the Souths game away next Fri nght then? Another loss?

What's your point? Are you nitpicking that I don't know the draw as well as you? Make a real point son!

 

[CocaCola]

Smackdown - BJ vs Daniel Vidot

 

[LeichhardtTiger]

Would you drop a player who has done his time? Faced public & media humiliation? Noel Kelly says Hi.

 

[Lauren]


The real Warren Smith. Being a bit harsh isn't he?

Warren who hasbeen

Wow that's a bit dramatic from Warren. As stupid as his actions were, he still adds a lot to this team.
I honestly believe he needs a bit of an attitude adjustment. Surely he can see that this team has nothing naturally gifted to them and has to work extra hard, in every facet. Can't defend his actions at all but understand his frustrations toward the refereeing decisions about the high hits from Panthers - think I saw Doueihi hit up around the neck, throat and chin 3 times.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

My issue with all this is that we are going to pay for it for much longer than the 10 minutes he was sin binned.

This stupidity will now cost us for the next 1-4 weeks depending on his suspension. A dumb play with no upside for the team.

16 players busted their gut to get us in a position to win and he throws it all away with that behaviour. We are primed to get knocked off by the Broncos...

Peter Sterling highlighted the kicking the ball away incident which resulted in a try and then when he hogged the ball instead of passing it to Nofoaluma. You just cannot carry high maintenance players in your team especially when playing the top teams. It will always cost you.

 

[JC99]

Joey facing 6 weeks if he appeals his charge and fails. Probably 5 with an early guilty plea

 

[Needaname]

My issue with all this is that we are going to pay for it for much longer than the 10 minutes he was sin binned.

This stupidity will now cost us for the next 1-4 weeks depending on his suspension. A dumb play with no upside for the team.

16 players busted their gut to get us in a position to win and he throws it all away with that behaviour. We are primed to get knocked off by the Broncos...

Peter Sterling highlighted the kicking the ball away incident which resulted in a try and then when he hogged the ball instead of passing it to Nofoaluma. You just cannot carry high maintenance players in your team especially when playing the top teams. It will always cost you.

My issue with all this is that we are going to pay for it for much longer than the 10 minutes he was sin binned.

This stupidity will now cost us for the next 1-4 weeks depending on his suspension. A dumb play with no upside for the team.

16 players busted their gut to get us in a position to win and he throws it all away with that behaviour. We are primed to get knocked off by the Broncos...

Peter Sterling highlighted the kicking the ball away incident which resulted in a try and then when he hogged the ball instead of passing it to Nofoaluma. You just cannot carry high maintenance players in your team especially when playing the top teams. It will always cost you.

My issue with all this is that we are going to pay for it for much longer than the 10 minutes he was sin binned.

This stupidity will now cost us for the next 1-4 weeks depending on his suspension. A dumb play with no upside for the team.

16 players busted their gut to get us in a position to win and he throws it all away with that behaviour. We are primed to get knocked off by the Broncos...

Peter Sterling highlighted the kicking the ball away incident which resulted in a try and then when he hogged the ball instead of passing it to Nofoaluma. You just cannot carry high maintenance players in your team especially when playing the top teams. It will always cost you.

Ironically if your still watching you’ll be seeing the appraisal they are giving Moses Suli. He was a MASSIVE retention loss for us.

 

[Needaname]

Joey facing 6 weeks if he appeals his charge and fails. Probably 5 with an early guilty plea

4 in the report.

 

[hobbo1]

Joey facing 6 weeks if he appeals his charge and fails. Probably 5 with an early guilty plea

Wow
That’s a bit rich ..

What about Korisau’s dog shot ?

 

[bptiger]

If joeys looking at 4-6 weeks for that effort then the Penrith hooker must get 10-12 weeks , joeys effort was stupid but there was no force it was more a sling action .

 

[avocadoontoast]

If joeys looking at 4-6 weeks for that effort then the Penrith hooker must get 10-12 weeks , joeys effort was stupid but there was no force it was more a sling action .

He clotheslined a bloke who wasn’t even in the play. Force or no force he definitely deserves to be suspended.