Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Terrible terrible decision re Hastings... Hastings not being considered a 7 and picking Bateman over Hastings are two big mistakes by Sheens. And yet somehow Brooks still survives... astonished
I don't think the talk of Bateman coming had anything to do with it. The fact is he wasn't going to play 7 here and didn't want to play at 13 or 14. Newcastle offered him the 7 jersey and a hefty pay rise. No brainer really - good luck to him.
 
Unbelievable , great news all round, and what do we get ? Brooks haters.
Hastings ,was not a half, either is AD, and Brooks has to lift his game.
Solution - piss off to newcastle, you are not worth the money your on and you are not a FB, centre , or half, not needed for 2024. LB, improve your game or you can join them.
Laurie and a few others,-- we are not f ing around anymore, lift your games or theres the door.

At last a professional management with gonads, that can identify talent, and more important can identify duds.
So do u think Luke Brooks is an organising halfback to take us to a premiership
 
Does any 1 know if we have signed kurt falls? We really need a good backup jock madden type player
Definitely need another half as back up I reckon. I wonder if we would have a crack at that young gun kid (Karl Oloapu) who is unhappy with the Broncos (pending a release). Sheens is the type of coach to give a shot to a young kid if they are good enough.
 
Definitely need another half as back up I reckon. I wonder if we would have a crack at that young gun kid (Karl Oloapu) who is unhappy with the Broncos (pending a release). Sheens is the type of coach to give a shot to a young kid if they are good enough.
Kid looks very talented...

I read he's linked to dolphins.

Very much looks like a Sheens type of player.
They should definitely hold talks.
 
Fonua Pole extension news is excellent. Typically the kind of player we’d lose but the investment in youth seems to be working.

Of the crop that came through this year I thought he seemed most at home in first grade.

When you think about Utoikamanu, Pole, Matamua, Klemmer, Papali’i, Koroisau, you’ve got a big bunch of bodies to contend with.

Plenty to be excited about in the forwards which isn’t something you could traditionally say about a Wests Tigers team.
I want Pole to be an "off the back fence" style of runner.
 
Kid looks very talented...

I read he's linked to dolphins.

Very much looks like a Sheens type of player.
They should definitely hold talks.
Yeah I think he had some links to Redcliffe too. But maybe he idolised Benji growing up...who knows. The timing could work out alright with a Top 30 spot for a backup half now available with us.

It seems his time at Broncos is definitely up. Just whether or not they release him.
 
This Caleb Clark mail is 100% fake news. Categorically denied. I wont be verifying POM's mail in the future. At least 90% of his mail comes back to me as wrong and it makes me feel like an idiot with my source.

On Woods, it's a done deal. It'll be announced at a later date.
Was the Hastings mail wrong?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
I just can't believe this.

It was obvious even with Jackson's downsides,he was the best organizer we've
had in ages.He played behind a beaten pack too just like Brooks.

We've always had the troops blamed for general Brooks.

Teddy,MM,Brooks----Kept Brooks
Hastings,AD,Brooks--Kept Brooks

I hope Sheens and Benji can unleash something in Brooks we haven't seen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
So do u think Luke Brooks is an organising halfback to take us to a premiership
Can't you read ? Brooks and AD have contracts we have no choice for 23. I mentioned LB as well as AD being shown the door ! We are a long way from a premiership, most of the players in the comp will have retired by the time we finish in the top 2 (if ever) . The aim is to build a competitive side, grow and develop juniors , and buy and discard players as needed. It,s not to pander to forum favourites who have no clue,
 
Yes he gets them wrong a lot. Again though Penrith have another class player at 6 who has a short kicking game also so it reduces the pressure on him. I know why people bag him for it but still think his poor kicking is often a result of pressure.
yeah I get that, but surely you get better the more you do something.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
This Caleb Clark mail is 100% fake news. Categorically denied. I wont be verifying POM's mail in the future. At least 90% of his mail comes back to me as wrong and it makes me feel like an idiot with my source.

On Woods, it's a done deal. It'll be announced at a later date.
Woods and Klemmer...there you go.
 

Members online

Back
Top