Stefano Utoikamanu #241

I am obviously a bit different I though our forwards weren’t that bad except for the may try. It was our outside backs that were really poor, Doueihi and faatape coming in all nite like last week was outlet major problem. The rooters saw them last week and attacked them all nite. Bad coaching to one not identify it at training and two to not run Fainu and stef at their midget halves all day is just beyond me. Bunji talking about JWH all week is fine but behind the close doors I am telling them to run at the halve.
Exactly. Down by 20 in 8 mins and you immediately take the forwards battle out of the game and start playing catch up football.

Put down the stats sheet, watch the events on the field.
 
I've read many of the posts here, but not all. Obviously there are some on this forum supporting Steff and others who want him gone. That's all good - it's what a forum is.
FWIW, I think Steff has above average ability and can be a damaging front rower on his day. But 'his day' is never against the big packs with tough front rowers. If he was ever going to be 'our Payne Hass', he should have be salivating at the thought of taking on Lenui, Collins and JWH and showing that he belongs in that company.
He didn't. He did nothing to show he's their equal. A fair dinkum, elite, tough front rower would have taken these guys on - got crunched, picked himself up and gone at them again and again and again. That's when you earn respect. That's when you show you are worth the big bucks. It's the stuff that JWH has been doing for a decade. It's the stuff that Beetson, Donelly, Roach and Webcke did for a decade in their era.
Of course he's not responsible for the performance of the team as a whole, but he is for his own performance.
And 54 metres in a game is pathetic.
 
I've read many of the posts here, but not all. Obviously there are some on this forum supporting Steff and others who want him gone. That's all good - it's what a forum is.
FWIW, I think Steff has above average ability and can be a damaging front rower on his day. But 'his day' is never against the big packs with tough front rowers. If he was ever going to be 'our Payne Hass', he should have be salivating at the thought of taking on Lenui, Collins and JWH and showing that he belongs in that company.
He didn't. He did nothing to show he's their equal. A fair dinkum, elite, tough front rower would have taken these guys on - got crunched, picked himself up and gone at them again and again and again. That's when you earn respect. That's when you show you are worth the big bucks. It's the stuff that JWH has been doing for a decade. It's the stuff that Beetson, Donelly, Roach and Webcke did for a decade in their era.
Of course he's not responsible for the performance of the team as a whole, but he is for his own performance.
And 54 metres in a game is pathetic.

I’m not saying you are wrong … but why do so many other clubs want him ?
 
how do you feel about them paying Klemmer $800k a year for 4 years ?
I don't like that either, that is a mistake we are stuck with. If Rumours were true we tried to move klemmer on last year
Right now we can do something about making another mistake and re-signing another overpriced pillow !
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Seyfarth makes more metres,hits harder and competes further, he’s been the forum scapegoat for years 🤔
Not sure if Stef is tanking or genuinely isn’t up to it ,but for 800k you want your props to go toe to toe with the big dogs.
We were outclassed in every position last night but you still expect your “marquee” players to step up,not sure if he ever reaches his potential with us .
 
I don't like that either, that is a mistake we are stuck with. If Rumours were true we tried to move klemmer on last year
Right now we can do something about making another mistake and re-signing another overpriced pillow !

They just signed Klemmer last year ??

Stef is gone … don’t worry about it …

he would have signed already if he was staying … I don’t know who is going to replace him …any ideas ? Gotta replace Ice too
 
I've read many of the posts here, but not all. Obviously there are some on this forum supporting Steff and others who want him gone. That's all good - it's what a forum is.
FWIW, I think Steff has above average ability and can be a damaging front rower on his day. But 'his day' is never against the big packs with tough front rowers. If he was ever going to be 'our Payne Hass', he should have be salivating at the thought of taking on Lenui, Collins and JWH and showing that he belongs in that company.
He didn't. He did nothing to show he's their equal. A fair dinkum, elite, tough front rower would have taken these guys on - got crunched, picked himself up and gone at them again and again and again. That's when you earn respect. That's when you show you are worth the big bucks. It's the stuff that JWH has been doing for a decade. It's the stuff that Beetson, Donelly, Roach and Webcke did for a decade in their era.
Of course he's not responsible for the performance of the team as a whole, but he is for his own performance.
And 54 metres in a game is pathetic.
You’re forgetting it’s a forward ‘pack’ though.

Have a think about the environment the greats, the Webcke’s and Haas’ play/ed in. Their packs were always extremely dominant. They have origin and international players everywhere.

To be clear Stef isn’t in their class. He may never be.

But running metres stats really aren’t comparable when your team is getting their pants pulled down all over the shop.

Stef’s value will be determined by the market, 800-900K seems about right based on his career trajectory in my opinion.

Edit: I think even Payne Haas collected a wooden spoon in a poo side.
 
Last edited:
9 runs for 54 metres, so 6 metres average per run.
So if Stef values himself at 1 million per season does that mean at 40k per game his runs are worth $4,444 each or his tackles are worth $1,176 each?
 
You’re forgetting it’s a forward ‘pack’ though.

Have a think about the environment the greats, the Webcke’s and Haas’ play/ed in. Their packs were always extremely dominant. They have origin and international players everywhere.

To be clear Stef isn’t in their class. He may never be.

But running metres stats really aren’t comparable when your team is getting their pants pulled down all over the shop.

Stef’s value will be determined by the market, 800-900K seems about right based on his career trajectory in my opinion.

Edit: I think even Payne Haas collected a wooden spoon in a poo side.
I concede your point re the quality of the rest of the pack - and I didn't forget about that. It should, however, make zero difference to his output if he's playing in the best pack in the comp or for the WestsTigers.

He will never be 'top dog' in the ranks of front rowers until his mindset changes and performs regardless of team mates or opposition. He may be exactly what the Storm want because they already have leaders and a great team around him - and perhaps that is what Stef needs to perform at his best.

But it's not what our team needs. We need mongrel middles who will fire up regardless. We need the ''follow me boys" type of players. I'm not sure where we find them - perhaps guys like Hunt would fit the bill.
I wasn't sure until yesterday whether we should break the bank to keep him. I now firmly believe we should not.
 
Pathetic performance really, really cements the idea that he's not worth $800k.

I thought maybe he had turned a corner after the previous couple of weeks, but he continually demonstrates that he goes missing the moment the team goes through some adversity.

Again it's completely laughable that he sees himself as a leader.
 
Back
Top