Cooper Cronk Released From Storm

Cronk is a brilliant player but he is probably not what we want, we probably need to spend 1.2 mil on three or four very good NRL standard players and not put all our eggs in the one basket. It will certainly help us retain our off contract players. I think Hasler will chase him hard
 
@ said:
@ said:
Well as much as I rate Cronk, are we seriously going to throw away two promising youngsters in Brooks and Moses for Cooper Cronk for let's say 2 seasons max. Yes Broses are commanding a lot of money, and I don't agree with the amount they are APPARENTLY asking for…... if I'd throw money at another half it'd be Jack Bird. I'd love Cronk at the club but not for both Brooks and Moses, if we just told Brooks to leave and kept Micth I think Moses will learn a lot from Cronk on trying to contain the consistency he had at the end of 2016, Cronk is one of the smartest league players to play the game and his footy brain and experience will bring a lot to the success of this great club in the years to come.

Of course we would keep one of them, it would be Brooks for me.

6\. Brooks
7\. Cronk

Cheaper and I think he would benefit more.

Sounds good to me.
 
@ said:
Well as much as I rate Cronk, are we seriously going to throw away two promising youngsters in Brooks and Moses for Cooper Cronk for let's say 2 seasons max. Yes Broses are commanding a lot of money, and I don't agree with the amount they are APPARENTLY asking for…... if I'd throw money at another half it'd be Jack Bird. I'd love Cronk at the club but not for both Brooks and Moses, if we just told Brooks to leave and kept Micth I think Moses will learn a lot from Cronk on trying to contain the consistency he had at the end of 2016, Cronk is one of the smartest league players to play the game and his footy brain and experience will bring a lot to the success of this great club in the years to come.

We don't have two promising youngsters,….oh yeah...we do.... Brooks and Suli , sorry!
 
There are opinions aplenty on this forum about Cronk but I wonder what Wests Tigers' coach and management ideas would be? If it is positive it could spearhead the club into 2018.
 
Sign him till the end of '19 then sign Cleary Jnr :smiley:

Seriously though, not gonna happen. What it could do though is give our halves no choice but to stay. I don't see this impacting us retaining Tedesco though.
 
Nope. He'd suit a team that has the squad to compete for the title in the next 2 years. We're not that team. He wouldn't be good value for us at all. Better off spending money elsewhere imo.
 
O M G

WE HAVE TO **HAVE TO** MAKE A SERIOUS PLAY FOR HIM!!!!!!!!!

MAKE WESTS TIGERS GREAT AGAIN!

Cleary, Marina Go, Pascoe, Board Members, Sponsors, the ghost of Laurie Nicholls, whoever, please make this happen!

Cronk signing means all faith will be restored. It represents intent.

Don't listen to any doubters, there is just no such thing as paying overs for Cronk.
GO ALL OUT! BREAK THE BANK!

MAKE WESTS TIGERS GREAT AGAIN!
 
Wow talk about blowing a few uncontracted footballers out of the water! Broses will not like this news at all.

I'd love to know who has the money to afford Cronk right now, a million bucks free for next season. See the papers made all this nonsense talk about Tigers "allowing their top players to all be off contract at the same time" but not only did/do other clubs face that reality this year, it also allows you to make big changes to your roster when big events like this happen on the market.

Dragons just put down a lot of cash for Ben Hunt, might have some free money if Dugan leaves, but they'll be wanting to tie Widdop down surely? I don't know if any club can really afford two million-dollar footballers in the halves. If Dragons were to play for Cronk, they'd probably have to not re-sign Dugan and withdraw anything they may have offered for Tedesco. I don't see it.

Dogs, well they look likely to clear Reynolds but Moses Mbye is still on a pretty rich deal. They could sign Cronk in theory… they are blooding a few young guys right now who would be up for new contracts around when Cronk would retire. It's just the question of how much money they have tied up in their forward pack already and how long the Morris twins have to run on their contracts.

Sharks are no chance, they have enough trouble retaining their current roster.

I don't see Manly, again the the issue of already spending $1M in your halves. Plus Manly have a lot of new recruits, I can't see them having much spare.

Parramatta - possibly. But again Norman is going to be on big dollars, they'd probably be able to make space but would have to go light somewhere front or back. In other words you can't have $2M in the halves, a million-dollar forward and a million-dollar fullback.

Souths - Reynolds was re-signed as was Cody Walker. GI and S Burgess are early days into rich deals.

Penrith - no chance, they are locked for halves just now.

Broncos would be all over this if not for the fact Cronk is leaving specifically for Sydney. Bad luck for them, they look like missing out on Ash Taylor too.

That leaves Tigers to consider. Lots of room to move here, so many contracts ending in 2017\. Tigers have no money committed to the halves yet and previous talk was of pretty big salaries, so you'd have to imagine we could mobilise the kind of pay Cronk would command. Big question is whether we do this for a short-term gain, because you'd surely have to let go of one or both of Broses. Those boys, if they get it together, could have many years in front of them, Cronk has perhaps 2.

But as the paper noted Cronk is on the back of Dally M and Golden Boot, he is a fitness fanatic and doesn't have a history of bad injury. He'd be a decent bet to stay fit and firing for the contract duration.

So the second big question becomes - if we were to seriously go for Cronk, what do you do with the 5/8th spot? At this time Moses is the clear 5/8th, but he's also probably the most expensive of Broses and also the biggest risk I think (variable form and always a question in defence).

Or come at it from another angle, what happens if you do get an agreement from Cronk, because surely he's keen to talk turkey soon, what if you get Cronk in and then turn back to Tedesco, Woods etc. and say: "this is our tentpole signing, to build the club around next 2-3 seasons". You only need a few good years to set up a new culture/direction for a club.

Or we can keep the underperforming kids we have, and just hope the new coach can do some magic?

I would LOVE for Cronk to come to Tigers, easily the biggest-name signing we'd ever have had.
 
Oh and Roosters, their halves are set already.

If nothing else, this puts WT in a much stronger bargaining position with Broses because clubs will now be looking at Cronk instead of Broses, a Ferrari instead of a Fiat, if you will.

Unless Broses want to go to Melbourne, I hear there is a big opening down there.
 
@ said:
Nope. He'd suit a team that has the squad to compete for the title in the next 2 years. We're not that team. He wouldn't be good value for us at all. Better off spending money elsewhere imo.

Why not? We have a major deficiency in attacking structure, developing and maintaining pressure, clutch football and sensible plays.

Cronk is exactly a solution to those issues, proven fit and dependable footballer, off a very good 2016 season with no obvious sign of form drop.

Add Cronk and would we not go a good way closer to competing for the title, in most opinions?

The thing about clubs that you would rate as "premiership contenders" right now, they have pretty full rosters with well-paid and consistent footballers. They typically do not have huge "war chests" to spend. Normally these clubs make big signings after the departure of an existing big signing.

How, for example, would Roosters manage their roster to fit in a player like Cronk? They've already committed to Pearce and Keary.
 
I'd be making it public that we are negotiating to put the pressure back on Broses. IMO we should only be keeping one of them anyway Brookes being my preference partly due to price. In saying that id take a punt on the current Qld and Aust representative Half over what we have holding us to ransom at the moment.

I bet Uncle Issac is soiling himself over not biting the hands off our offer last year.
 
We need experienced half to teach (one of) ours …..
and Melbourne needs a young promising half who can be taught by Bellamy/Smith/Slater.
Seems a good swap/fit to me!
 
I would absolutely be making a play for Cronk, he is on $1M per year at the Storm so a figure around that could land him. Then we could offer the balance of the "Broses Fund" to Mitch, take it or leave it. A player like Cronk only has 2 more years to play, but he is a player to rebuild a club around. Great work ethic, spirit and pride in his work. The young guys look up to him and they will learn a lot from his example.

He will also help to fix the biggest problem at our club - our culture.

Don't be fooled by the "big 4" myth, these boys are not worth anywhere near what they are asking. We have all 4 at the moment and we are dead last!
 
Cronk would also be great in a coaching role at the Tigers after his career is over given he is one of the premier halves running around plus the knowledge he would have gleaned from Bellamy over the years.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top