HBG, Independent Directors Sacked

cochise said:
Yes his results are very good, in a lower tier sport. You also can't compare his cv to richo's, they aren't in the same universe.

Im not saying skando and galea don't have anything to offer, but look what you are losing. Do you think they have the government and political connections that a former premier has, or the corporate governance experience of someone that has sat on the boards of swimming Australia?

How are you replacing those skills? Also don't forget the dismissed directors were appointed against a skills matrix, why aren't we looking for people that meet the highest possible standards?
Click to expand...
At some point Richardson would retire & Meilekamp was brought into the building as a likely successor. Of the options available- I think he's the best one.

I agree- guys like Skando & Galea do not offer the political or financial clout of some of the previous directors. That said, a certain amount of football gene pool for the club wouldn't be a bad thing. Does the club need some further reaching hands? Yes. But in an attempt to rectify a ruptured club structure, some Wests Tigers bloodlines on the board- not Balmain or Magpies- could be a bridge required.
 
tigertragic said:
From all reports the conditions of the clauses in richos contract were all tied to retention of BOF and the independent WT Board ongoing. Obviously Richo had seen previous HBG management ‘activities/honesty’
Click to expand...
Every public appearance he made, he went to great lengths to assert that he was making the decisions along with his board and he didn’t expect interference from the shareholders. For them to use poor communication against him (well against half his board actually) is in my opinion, a weak gutted cop out.

Hopefully the full story is out eventually.
 
liltiger said:
How many clubs in the gutter has he raised to win comps. Richo had 2 here, 1 in England. They're not even in the same solar system.
Click to expand...
There is a significant age difference to account for too. If we are only looking for like-for-like appointments, the selection process is going to offer slim pickings.

At some point, younger blood steps in.
 
The_Patriot said:
Chammas obviously on the Isaac Moses and Pascoe side of things.

Richardson may have not been perfect but he was getting results and the club was finally moving forward after years of mistakes

I'll take Richardsons mistakes given the upside he was bringing over other and future guys who have and will be more your Luke Brooks type with mistakes with an average ceiling.
Click to expand...
Yes, every criticism Chammas has over Richo, such as mistreatment of Klemmer/Bateman as well as dropping 2nd rate top 30 players to syd cup and shopping players to English clubs, were things he should be praised for and which contributed to the improvement of the club.

He wasn't perfect on everything, but there was a lot of agenda driven perspective from Chammas that was surprisingly one sided. Chammas seemed more aligned to Pascoe and Lee than Moses in the way he complained about the way Richo criticised them and the club.

Chammas also said that Benji is not talking to him which suggests another grievance Chammas probably holds against the club. You can understand that Chammas, as a journalist, is trying to get his own back a bit after getting everything leaked to him in previous regime while getting the cold shoulder from the current crew. Obviously then uses his media role to criticise those who aren't giving him scoops and playing the media game.
 
Last edited:
hammertime said:
Montgomery was the rep, but then replaced leo <insert last name here>. Again, showing their instability.

Leo was inducted as a new debenture holder recently.
Click to expand...
So you mean Leo Epifania played 23 games for Wests, HBG debenture holder, one time assistant coach of Italy and was GM of Wests Cup side from 2015 according to Wiki but,.... not a HBG board member according to their website?
 
The Chad said:
Sure. Why not?

Wayne Pearce, one of my favourite players of all time, got a job as a coach. Then he got appointed to various boards over time. He's something to do with the ARL now isn't he? Commission Chair or something?

Why can't well spoken football guys, like Skandalis & Ben Galea offer something at Board level for the Tigers? Skando has worked for the club since retiring. Galea works as a video referee, so has links with the NRL now.

Why not guys like that? I don't imagine HBG are offering better options.

I'd rather a board that has their heart in the club.
Click to expand...
No disrespect Chad, but these are the ramblings of someone whet behind the ears and like I said yesterday, has a hint of naivety to it.

I'm afraid you live in a Utopia where love conquers all, but I'm here to tell you, this isn't Silicon Valley where a 21 year old is the brains behind a mega company and it's not Doogie Howser where a 13 year old becomes a doctor and saves lives.

We need a battle hardened CEO that's had success repeatedly against all odds and lived to tell the tale...that was Richo.
 
Last edited:
weststigers said:
No disrespect Chad, but these are the ramblings of someone whet between the ears and like I said yesterday, has a hint of naivety to it.

I'm afraid you live in a Utopia where love conquers all, but I'm here to tell you, this isn't Silicon Valley where a 21 year old is the brains behind a mega company and it's not Doogie Howser where a 13 year old becomes a doctor and saves lives.

We need a battle hardened CEO that's had success repeatedly against all odds and lived to tell the tale...that was Richo.
Click to expand...
So only Richo can save the Tigers?

He just resigned.

No need for a rally on Saturday then?
 
watersider said:
Yes, every criticism Chammas has over Richo, such as mistreatment of Klemmer/Bateman as well as dropping 2nd rate top 30 players to syd cup and shopping players to English clubs, were things he should be praised for and which contributed to the improvement of the club. He wasn't perfect on everything, but there was a lot of agenda driven perspective from Chammas that was surprisingly one sided. Chammas seemed more aligned to Pascoe and Lee than Moses in the way he complained about the way Richo criticised them and the club. Chammas also said that Benji is not talking to him which suggests another grievance Chammas probably holds against the club. You can understand that Chammas, as a journalist, is trying to get his own back a bit after getting everything leaked to him in previous regime while getting the cold shoulder from the current crew. Obviously then uses his media role to criticise those who aren't giving him scoops and playing the media game.
Click to expand...
I don't want to be "that guy", but your post would have more impact with some paragraphs. Please don't take this the wrong way. My apologies in advance.
 
The Chad said:
There is a significant age difference to account for too. If we are only looking for like-for-like appointments, the selection process is going to offer slim pickings.

At some point, younger blood steps in.
Click to expand...
That's the point, shouldn't need like for like as we had the first part of the comparison.
 
WestsEffTheRest said:
. @BZN @Bus 2 Terrigal You both are a disgrace to Magpie legends like Tommy who were behind the joint venture from day 1 and celebrated this club openly & proudly. Do you guys agree with the actions of Wests Ashfield that are driving away young fans in droves including @tigahhh @WesternSuburbsBoy on here?
Click to expand...
Why exactly do you feel I am a disgrace?

What have I said that has you forming this rather vitriolic assessment ?

Please supply quotes 👍
 
cochise said:
That's the point, shouldn't need like for like as we had the first part of the comparison.
Click to expand...
Yes- but he resigned.

And there's some chance the NRL might have something to say about what he was doing.

Now- it's a viable option for everyone to look back at their calendar to last week & think nice thoughts. Or...shrug your shoulders & move on.

The club has to find someone new.

I think Mielekamp is the best option at this time.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,236 (members: 29, guests: 1,207)
Back
Top