Tom Shines
Well-known member
Geez there are some Muppets on here. While IP definitely didn't set the ground on fire with his performances, for anyone to say he didn't put in the effort is just wrong. You don't make 40 tackles a game if you're not putting in.
He's just not the player we need, if he were going to stay he would be joining our middles rotation.
We need a line breaking second rower with power and a bit of speed, someone who breaks tackles.
In the end we weren't getting good value out of him and told him he was free to leave. He didn't quit, we pushed him out. 750k for him is way overs, he's not a game changing player. Is he in the top 6-7 second rowers in comp? No. He's above average bit over his career he's just solid. The fact the Panthers ending up paying ice almost as much as they were prepared to pay Fifita says a lot about their desperation.
Suggestions we should just keep Ice go now are absurd. Just sheer stupidity. We currently have 4 back rowers in our top 30 and development players. This includes Tumeth who can barely get on the bench in cup. Bateman is having his worse season in the NRL ever, he's been appalling, much worse than Ice. We desperately want to get rid of him, hence Richo traveling to the UK. Naden, toa and Bateman I'd all release immediately if there were takers, ice at least works hard and can contribute
Now we just need to offload Bateman and we can get a decent second row next season
Offloading the players is the easy part … at this present moment they are weaker next season …
$750k is overs for sure …he must be on a contract that goes up every year …he was on $600k his first year .,
I ask who is coming into the Top 17 team to replace IP from inside this squad ? We see our benchies Seyfarth and Twal …not much there… they will be extending AJ soon and promoting him to the starting side if Richo doesn’t dig up someone soon,,,