JAC

[Speed2burn]

What’s the big deal in getting jac the guys a winger playing in a gun side. Down in Melbourne big difference playing in a very average side like ours you’ll see how really good he is then no bodies gunna come to us if we sign jac he’s not that big a signing

He's already played for our 'very average side' and looked good doing it.


Only telling the truth mate we are a very average side I seen jac play for us never really set the world on fire only that he was quick and if McGuire swaps talau (who had a lot of interest from the storm when he was playing sgball ) then he’s crazy

We aren’t swapping anyone lol, why would we when melbourne has AGREED to release Addo-Carr?

 

[earl]

The NEW Wests Tigers goal should be to pay our best performers the best money.

This is the goal that the club should have. We should be looking to good value out of our most highly paid players.

 

[fibrodreaming]

Who said Adam Doueihi is on 650k? Highly doubt he is on that much. It was reported his deal was around 400k/year with Souths chipping in his 1st year here

You'r right, that is what I recall as well.

I notice that some of our colleagues pull numbers from their you-know-where depending on the argument they are trying to make.

 

[the_third]

Is JAC really that big a scalp??
Not a proper big kill like Munster would be.

This.

Most clubs have a production line of good wingers. Look at roosters, panthers, Cronulla, manly....

With all respect to JAC. He’s pretty old for a winger these days also seems a tad 1 dimensional.

He is the best winger around, but it’s not a high cost position if you get the juniors right. If we get him, we would be paying our wingers around a million combined (give or take). That’s ridiculous money for that position. We need him or nofo - not both. The money is better spent elsewhere.

Staines would be a bargain compared to JAC

Munster would be a game changer for us

 

[Roar_Power]

I am sure when Doueihi signed it averaged out at $550k per annum over 4 years after top ups paid by the bunnies.

 

[Viking Warrior]

Lol cant believe people don't want a current international and origin player. Jac runs rings around the rest of our team literally.

 

[gallagher]

Lol cant believe people don't want a current international and origin player. Jac runs rings around the rest of our team literally.

I dont know where to start in replying to some posts. We dont want a walk up starter for the kangaroos? I'm flabergasted.

 

[Viking Warrior]

I am sure when Doueihi signed it averaged out at $550k per annum over 4 years after top ups paid by the bunnies.

Overs imo

 

[avocadoontoast]

Lol cant believe people don't want a current international and origin player. Jac runs rings around the rest of our team literally.

I dont know where to start in replying to some posts. We dont want a walk up starter for the kangaroos? I'm flabergasted.

We’re apparently going terribly because it’s not Madge’s roster but we also don’t want to sign anyone.

 

[gallagher]

Lol cant believe people don't want a current international and origin player. Jac runs rings around the rest of our team literally.

I dont know where to start in replying to some posts. We dont want a walk up starter for the kangaroos? I'm flabergasted.

We’re apparently going terribly because it’s not Madge’s roster but we also don’t want to sign anyone.

Yeah, we got this guy that might be good in three years time..

 

[avocadoontoast]

Lol cant believe people don't want a current international and origin player. Jac runs rings around the rest of our team literally.

I dont know where to start in replying to some posts. We dont want a walk up starter for the kangaroos? I'm flabergasted.

We’re apparently going terribly because it’s not Madge’s roster but we also don’t want to sign anyone.

Yeah, we got this guy that might be good in three years time..

And we cannot pay overs. They should WANT to come here.

 

[Masterton]

Look, I favour JAC at the right price WITHOUT a positional guarantee. But I'm sure plenty noticed his lack of ability to contest bombs against Fergo just yesterday.

 

[Goldust]

I’m all for JAC ,at the right price
Let’s pay 650 for a winger who ‘wants to play fullback’
Didn’t contest once against Ferguson last night got folded every hit up he took out of his own half.
He is an amazing winger,but he needs good ball
Our team is not going to give it to him
I think we can all see that.
Yeah want him in our squad I just don’t want to pay him ‘fullback money’ for everyone to asking for his head when we still fail to make the 8

 

[Geo]

Is Staines even proven? I remember we had a young fella called Jake Meaney who carved up in u20s aswell

Staines has polished off a few tries in a red hot penrith side.

I think you mean Jake Mullaney...and his Mum would agree..

Addo-Carr just has to decide where he wants to be,,he'll get a pay rise to come here..I reckon his agitation being an Origin player comes from learning what Fergo gets in comparison to what the Storm pay him..

Don't buy this fullback talk,,even as an un proven Fullback don't think Maguire would pay ridiculous money for him

Lets get him here..worry about the other stuff latter

 

[gallagher]

I’m all for JAC ,at the right price
Let’s pay 650 for a winger who ‘wants to play fullback’
Didn’t contest once against Ferguson last night got folded every hit up he took out of his own half.
He is an amazing winger,but he needs good ball
Our team is not going to give it to him
I think we can all see that.
Yeah want him in our squad I just don’t want to pay him ‘fullback money’ for everyone to asking for his head when we still fail to make the 8

The first big fish we hopefully land will be getting overs. Otherwise we'll never attract anyone. If he's terrible at fullback he'll be moved.

 

[Goldust]

I’m all for JAC ,at the right price
Let’s pay 650 for a winger who ‘wants to play fullback’
Didn’t contest once against Ferguson last night got folded every hit up he took out of his own half.
He is an amazing winger,but he needs good ball
Our team is not going to give it to him
I think we can all see that.
Yeah want him in our squad I just don’t want to pay him ‘fullback money’ for everyone to asking for his head when we still fail to make the 8

The first big fish we hopefully land will be getting overs. Otherwise we'll never attract anyone. If he's terrible at fullback he'll be moved.

Unfortunately that’s the position we are in
I just think we should be paying overs for prop or half
I totally get it but

 

[Cairnstigers]

So Bellamy wants Tommy Talu in return....”get stuffed”...take Jennings or nothing.....

Addo carr plays right wing at Melbourne
A trade for Nofoaluma could work
It would probably still leave us with enough money for Stains as well
They both want fullback, they can fight it out with each other
Winner gets the fullback spot
The other gets the wing spot
Fail at fullback and go back to the wing

 

[gallagher]

I’m all for JAC ,at the right price
Let’s pay 650 for a winger who ‘wants to play fullback’
Didn’t contest once against Ferguson last night got folded every hit up he took out of his own half.
He is an amazing winger,but he needs good ball
Our team is not going to give it to him
I think we can all see that.
Yeah want him in our squad I just don’t want to pay him ‘fullback money’ for everyone to asking for his head when we still fail to make the 8

The first big fish we hopefully land will be getting overs. Otherwise we'll never attract anyone. If he's terrible at fullback he'll be moved.


Unfortunately that’s the position we are in
I just think we should be paying overs for prop or half
I totally get it but

Absolutely. You dont get a chance like this too often, if any mainstay kangaroo is off contract we should be going all out to sign him. We not strong enough in ANY position to be comfortble with who we have.

 

[Speed2burn]

Is Staines even proven? I remember we had a young fella called Jake Meaney who carved up in u20s aswell

Staines has polished off a few tries in a red hot penrith side.

I think you mean Jake Mullaney...and his Mum would agree..

Addo-Carr just has to decide where he wants to be,,he'll get a pay rise to come here..I reckon his agitation being an Origin player comes from learning what Fergo gets in comparison to what the Storm pay him..

Don't buy this fullback talk,,even as an un proven Fullback don't think Maguire would pay ridiculous money for him

Lets get him here..worry about the other stuff latter

That’s the one.

And I 100% agree with everything you just said

 

[marzie]

So Bellamy wants Tommy Talu in return....”get stuffed”...take Jennings or nothing.....

Addo carr plays right wing at Melbourne
A trade for Nofoaluma could work
It would probably still leave us with enough money for Stains as well
They both want fullback, they can fight it out with each other
Winner gets the fullback spot
The other gets the wing spot
Fail at fullback and go back to the wing

Addo Carr plays on the left and you wouldn't trade any of our outside backs to get him imo...bar Mbye