vlad
Well-known member
is this an omen ?
is this an omen ?
MOYLAN MAYBE RELEASED ..
- Thread starter 05TIGZ
- Start date
No inside info or anything but, I'm not giving us a chance to get Moylan. Lolo deserves a year at fullback and if he doesn't kick on, then we'll go back into the market for a fullback. Besides that, I just don't see Moylan fitting into next years team or Penrith releasing him without compensation.
The-moP
Well-known member
@ said:
How about we give Reynolds to Penrith, and they give us Moylan .. ??
earl
Well-known member
@ said:
That is a good idea.
greatodensraven
New member
Whether Moylan signs with us or not, nobody should be guaranteed any position.
Love_the_WestsTigers
Well-known member
@ said:
2040
And 2560
Moylans wants more than his 700k per season which rules a move to the Tigers as out of the question.
The way I see it is if the Sharks want him they will get him as they will release Maloney to the Knights so he can collect his cash. Manly could do the same with Blake Green. Titans are rumoured to be looking at Garth Brennan assistant coach at Panthers who could afford him also. We are no chance and should stay out of an overpriced underperforming player who has had plenty of time to shine.
The way I see it is if the Sharks want him they will get him as they will release Maloney to the Knights so he can collect his cash. Manly could do the same with Blake Green. Titans are rumoured to be looking at Garth Brennan assistant coach at Panthers who could afford him also. We are no chance and should stay out of an overpriced underperforming player who has had plenty of time to shine.
G
Guest
Guest
@ said:
The Tigers have 2 chances of getting Moylan, buckleys and stuff all.
@ said:
Jesus you are guillable TT.
The spoilt brat wants more money and Gus has moved him and his request to the backburner until the finals series is over.
The amount of people claiming depression these days is outrageous. Its mostly snowflakes chucking a tantrum when life gives them a curve ball.
dazza65
Well-known member
@ said:
Agree 100% Stryker, 100%
Tiger_Steve
New member
If you believe the press he is a lazy trainer and cuts corners. He gets away with it due to raw talent. IF this is true, we really don't want him. Also, I like the idea of a top 30 where the gap between the best and worst player is small. No stars with huge egos!
jirskyr
Well-known member
@ said:
I'd be really careful about that, we don't know what is truly going on. Especially to say that when one of our own players committed suicide, I would avoid making accusations about other people's apparent or not mental health. We just don't really know.
On the other hand if he has issues and needs time to deal with them, I don't think Tigers are desperate enough to want to get involved with that. It's like with Foran, the guy has had personal problems and he needed to be able to get his head straight, but he's also on to his 3rd club in 3 seasons.
vlad
Well-known member
@ said:
Maloney wants more $$ . A straight swap doesn't achieve that . Would cost him more in tolls & fuel too .
@ said:
Not gullible Stryker,just take things for what they are,he has personal issues I have heard,I'm not privy to any of the Panthers inner sanctum,but if he does have these problems then they should be dealt with accordingly,if Gould and co use this as an excuse for their own satisfaction then they are lower than a snakes belly…these sort of things should not be taken lightly or used to benefit themselves financially or Moylans benefit....suicide and depression have been the cause of fine young people ending life far early than needed,help is only a call away,there are more things to life than trying to use illness as an excuse to better yourself..
Toowoomba_Tiger
Well-known member
I want him.
I'm not convinced with Tui at fullback, albeit I have never seen him play there.
I would prefer a proven fullback like Moylan.
I'm also not convinced with Reynolds at 5/8th.
I would love to start the season with
1\. Moylan
6\. Tui
7\. Brooks
9\. Reynolds
14\. Liddle
Not sure Liddle is ready to play 80 mins and Reynolds would offer more at 9 than Matty Mac.
I think we might get more long term value out of Reynolds only playing 50 mins and preserving him a bit.
I think the big minutes Eiso can play justifies carrying a second hooker on the bench, depending on minutes we get from Matulino and Packer.
I'm not convinced with Tui at fullback, albeit I have never seen him play there.
I would prefer a proven fullback like Moylan.
I'm also not convinced with Reynolds at 5/8th.
I would love to start the season with
1\. Moylan
6\. Tui
7\. Brooks
9\. Reynolds
14\. Liddle
Not sure Liddle is ready to play 80 mins and Reynolds would offer more at 9 than Matty Mac.
I think we might get more long term value out of Reynolds only playing 50 mins and preserving him a bit.
I think the big minutes Eiso can play justifies carrying a second hooker on the bench, depending on minutes we get from Matulino and Packer.
@ said:
Wasn't that pretty much the same info as we heard about Lolohea before he signed? I mean, line him up next to Moylan and ask someone who doesn't know anything about either of them which one's less committed to his training and 95% would guess Lolo…
Teams that win *always* accommodate star players. The idea you can put together a top 30 of identically talented, hard working pros with no egos and no man management required at all is a fantasy. To win you need outstanding talent, and sometimes outstanding talent needs careful handling.
Tiger_Steve
New member
I disagree to a point. The outstanding talent also needs to fit into a culture and team environment. Letting the team star get away with poor behaviour/attitude/training sends bad message to the rest of the group. Look at Titans. We tried accommodating stars, look what happened. Storm have stars and are successful because the stars drive the positive culture. They don't work against it. Personally I'm happy with our new roster. Hopefully it's full of first grade standard talent with a common goal of working hard together to win games.
