On the right track with what? I'm seeing plenty about Ben Gardner, as if he had some influence with what was happening at the club. Is it merely because he had the reserve grade team running third at the end of a Covid affected season?
This is the problem with the reserve grade team:
Mason
Feledy
Faataape
Lobb
Laulilii
Sukkar
Porter
Who are they missing who regularly played last season? Sullivan, Naden, Miller, and Tumeth. Otherwise, the NRL representatives are the same as last season. What's changed appears to be the part-timers. So the team is weaker. Matamua and Tumeth can't even make this team (or the club doesn't want them).
Our NRL team also seem to have the most NRL injuries in the past few seasons other than Souths and Roosters. So the depth is tested even more.
Compare that with the team currently leading the comp and the players they've already pulled into their reserve grade team this season:
Berry
Harper
Kosi
Te Mare Martin
Tannah Boyd
Lussick
Afoa
Laban
Ale
Sam Healy
Stowers-Smith
Some of those guys played in an NRL game that defeated our NRL team only a week ago.
Yeah, Gardner would turn this lot into a bunch of winners. Yeah right! They all train with NRL don't they?The depth is bad. The hangover from Sheens/McDonnell's signings lingers in this grade. After this season, with the deadwood cut adrift, you should hope it will improve. It can't be any worse than this.
Really our NSW Cup team should be something like this IMO ...
Brent Naden - experience at the back, help direct defensive line, x-factor
Izaac Tui'tupou - former NRL winger & NSW Cup team of the year
Solomona Faataape - NRL contracted player, won a QCup premiership
Luke Laulilii - yes 18yo but one of our brightest outside back prospects
Charlie Staines - NRL quality
Heath Mason - running game, x-factor, his original position
Kurt Falls - experience, previous Penrith depth player
Jaxson Rahme - solid, young but has Cup experience
Tony Sukkar - held his own at NRL level, is on an upward trajectory
Reuben Porter or Elie El Zakhem - experience, solid NSW Cup players
Tim Johannssen - NSW Cup team of year, needs to play big minutes
Tristan Hope - captain, NRL depth, won a QCup premiership
Kit Laulilii - impact, is on an upward trajectory, working towards NRL
Bench of Vaka Aho, Justin Matamua, Brandon Tumeth, Bailey Hodges & numerous others in the mix.
It's not much different to what we ran out yesterday with some NRL additions in Naden & Staines. This team should be contending ... it has to be a coaching issue or something else going on behind-the-scenes affecting the intent of the squad in concentration & 1%ers.