Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Spud_Murphy]

FWIW I'm not hearing anything about players who are signed and in COP.

But the other bloke on here, supposedly in the know, says there are 2 in the COP! Who are us plebs supposed to believe??

I'd say go with the one who isn't a chronic attention seeker…or just ignore it all and wait and see what happens.

The latter sounds like good advice :slight_smile:

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Is James Roberts still off contract? We'd be mad if we didn't make him an offer!

 

[bigsiro]

Is James Roberts still off contract? We'd be mad if we didn't make him an offer!

Bonkers!
The best attacking centre in the game.
Gotta make him an offer. Let's test his resolve and at the very least make the market pay top dollar.
How he didn't walk into the NSW side over Dugan is a mystery and a damn tragedy.

 

[Seantice]

His defence is ordinary though.. Wouldnt pay more than average for him.

 

[teddy23]

Would've taken Moga any day before Roberts….... Knights got lucky there

I feel for Reynolyds seems like he's trying to create something all the time but gets no support, I reckon he'll do well at the Tigers

 

[Spud_Murphy]

That Benji Marshall goes alright too :laughing:

 

[Seantice]

Would've taken Moga any day before Roberts….... Knights got lucky there

I feel for Reynolyds seems like he's trying to create something all the time but gets no support, I reckon he'll do well at the Tigers

Moga is a big bodybthat can move. Should go ok.

Im not sold on Reynolds at all. Too much sideways running and wrong decisions. Has he even got a try assist this year?

 

[jirskyr]

FWIW I'm not hearing anything about players who are signed and in COP.

But the other bloke on here, supposedly in the know, says there are 2 in the COP! Who are us plebs supposed to believe??

I'd say go with the one who isn't a chronic attention seeker…or just ignore it all and wait and see what happens.

The latter sounds like good advice :slight_smile:

Honestly though who is the attention seeker - the bloke who posts scoops, or the bloke that posts counter-scoops? It's been tit for tat lately with all the scoopers.

 

[Roar_Power]

But the other bloke on here, supposedly in the know, says there are 2 in the COP! Who are us plebs supposed to believe??

I'd say go with the one who isn't a chronic attention seeker…or just ignore it all and wait and see what happens.

The latter sounds like good advice :slight_smile:

Honestly though who is the attention seeker - the bloke who posts scoops, or the bloke that posts counter-scoops? It's been tit for tat lately with all the scoopers.

Agree mate

 

[will1999]

I would love James Roberts he would be the speed we need and Moses Suli the strength in the centres

 

[Geo]

James Roberts will re-sign with the Broncos even if we offered 10million dollars..Dr Evil style..

 

[05TIGZ]

I'd say go with the one who isn't a chronic attention seeker…or just ignore it all and wait and see what happens.

The latter sounds like good advice :slight_smile:

Honestly though who is the attention seeker - the bloke who posts scoops, or the bloke that posts counter-scoops? It's been tit for tat lately with all the scoopers.

Agree mate

Scoops give us something to talk about. They don't always eventuate it, but I don't think the forum would be the same without them. So all the scoop posters keep them coming boys.

 

[TYGA]

Would've taken Moga any day before Roberts….... Knights got lucky there

I feel for Reynolyds seems like he's trying to create something all the time but gets no support, I reckon he'll do well at the Tigers

Moga is as good a defensive centre as Kyle Lovett. Great with the ball but will get exposed at the Knights. Roberts is light years better his speed covers his errors and he is lightning. Agree Reynolds is much better than he looks in the worst attacking team in the NRL. Will be great for 2-3 years not sure he has the skills to adapt when he slows down.

 

[king_sirro]

But the other bloke on here, supposedly in the know, says there are 2 in the COP! Who are us plebs supposed to believe??

I'd say go with the one who isn't a chronic attention seeker…or just ignore it all and wait and see what happens.

The latter sounds like good advice :slight_smile:

Honestly though who is the attention seeker - the bloke who posts scoops, or the bloke that posts counter-scoops? It's been tit for tat lately with all the scoopers.

If someone starts a "comeback" thread declaring they have graced the forum once again, if that same person then refers back to said thread months later by saying "if you read my comeback thread", then its safe to say that he is the attention seeking one.

I think Yoss is the most reliable personally.

 

[Nucky_Thompson]

Would've taken Moga any day before Roberts….... Knights got lucky there

I feel for Reynolyds seems like he's trying to create something all the time but gets no support, I reckon he'll do well at the Tigers

Moga is a big bodybthat can move. Should go ok.

Im not sold on Reynolds at all. Too much sideways running and wrong decisions. Has he even got a try assist this year?

If your looking at jr form this year there cause for concern.

It's well documented jr is loved by the dog fans and they blame Des coaching for his current form. The dogs combo of Reynolds Maye frowley leicca and hopp simply does not work.

Remains to be seen how Reynolds will be with cleary. Clear will definitely simplify his game

 

[Russell]

Hopefully Roberts will sign quickly with the Broncos - put Tacky out of his misery.

He is fast, that is a given and has a reasonable step usually always going left across field - does not have anything else to offer as far as I can see, apart from very ordinary defence and a reasonably short fuse. Would be a great mistake putting him in SOO - someone said he is better than Dugan - Yeah right in his dreams and Dugan is really a FB.

As far as people having a go at SG - if you think he is a wanker, a show pony or an attention seeker it is very simple - don't read his posts. I think he also has something to offer, keep up the good work SG. The more people that may know something the better imo.

As far as two signings in COP - it does not have to be high profile NRL players, it could be a couple of ISP youngsters - we do need to fill 30 places! I am sure all will be revealed shortly.

 

[momo_amp_medo]

Hopefully Roberts will sign quickly with the Broncos - put Tacky out of his misery.

He is fast, that is a given and has a reasonable step usually always going left across field - does not have anything else to offer as far as I can see, apart from very ordinary defence and a reasonably short fuse. Would be a great mistake putting him in SOO - someone said he is better than Dugan - Yeah right in his dreams and Dugan is really a FB.

As far as people having a go at SG - if you think he is a wanker, a show pony or an attention seeker it is very simple - don't read his posts. I think he also has something to offer, keep up the good work SG. The more people that may know something the better imo.

As far as two signings in COP - it does not have to be high profile NRL players, it could be a couple of ISP youngsters - we do need to fill 30 places! I am sure all will be revealed shortly.

X2

 

[tigerbenji]

Hope Smoking Gun keeps giving us info & anyone else who has some.

 

[WT2K]

Hopefully Roberts will sign quickly with the Broncos - put Tacky out of his misery.

He is fast, that is a given and has a reasonable step usually always going left across field - does not have anything else to offer as far as I can see, apart from very ordinary defence and a reasonably short fuse. Would be a great mistake putting him in SOO - someone said he is better than Dugan - Yeah right in his dreams and Dugan is really a FB.

As far as people having a go at SG - if you think he is a wanker, a show pony or an attention seeker it is very simple - don't read his posts. I think he also has something to offer, keep up the good work SG. The more people that may know something the better imo.

As far as two signings in COP - it does not have to be high profile NRL players, it could be a couple of ISP youngsters - we do need to fill 30 places! I am sure all will be revealed shortly.

X2

X3

 

[05TIGZ]

Hopefully Roberts will sign quickly with the Broncos - put Tacky out of his misery.

He is fast, that is a given and has a reasonable step usually always going left across field - does not have anything else to offer as far as I can see, apart from very ordinary defence and a reasonably short fuse. Would be a great mistake putting him in SOO - someone said he is better than Dugan - Yeah right in his dreams and Dugan is really a FB.

As far as people having a go at SG - if you think he is a wanker, a show pony or an attention seeker it is very simple - don't read his posts. I think he also has something to offer, keep up the good work SG. The more people that may know something the better imo.

As far as two signings in COP - it does not have to be high profile NRL players, it could be a couple of ISP youngsters - we do need to fill 30 places! I am sure all will be revealed shortly.

X2

X3

X4