Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Coastie_Tiger]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

No club is paying more than 150k for Mbye. They all have televisions,
He's the "Uncle Charlie" (You've got uncle Charlie, no you've got uncle Charlie) of the NRL.

Our only hope is Hodgo doing us a solid and taking him over to Super League.

You’re not wrong only we could be that stupid, if we don’t get anyone else in this year I would seriously think about using the rest of our cap space this year to front load him. That might make him semi appealing to someone even then we would still have to most likely carry some freight for him.

 

[hsvjones]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Agree and FULL Credit to you for watching the game again... That alone takes courage..

Maybe the club should make the players watch the game again to see how we all feel.

 

[hsvjones]

The POM/anyone else in the know, any updates on who we're chasing for next year?

2nd that.... we need something to look forward to as I now prefer to watch Wigan play then us.. @THE_POM

 

[Don Kershane]

If the plan is to keep Mbye in the shop window-it ain't working.

 

[izotope]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

Go watch the game again. Mbye literally caused 4 of the tries through lazy careless tackles and shirt grabbing. He needs to go

No way am i watching the game again
Ill take your word for it, for the most part i saw him containing fifita pretty well

 

[TigerTone]

Can anyone tell me please.
Is it after round ten or for round ten , that we can use players from our KOE team?

 

[TYGA]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

Go watch the game again. Mbye literally caused 4 of the tries through lazy careless tackles and shirt grabbing. He needs to go

No way am i watching the game again
Ill take your word for it, for the most part i saw him containing fifita pretty well

Mbye contained Fifita ?
They had to help with 3 players and caused massive numbers on the right. The sooner we wake up to this loafer the better.

Worst thing that you can have in a rebuilding team are the wrong senior players.

 

[Tigertragic83]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

Go watch the game again. Mbye literally caused 4 of the tries through lazy careless tackles and shirt grabbing. He needs to go

No way am i watching the game again
Ill take your word for it, for the most part i saw him containing fifita pretty well

Mbye contained Fifita ?
They had to help with 3 players and caused massive numbers on the right. The sooner we wake up to this loafer the better.

Worst thing that you can have in a rebuilding team are the wrong senior players.

His defence was not leader-worthy. One thing I did notice Is that people lost all faith in mbye to make his tackles. The try the Titans scored in the second half mbye had a lazy air swing. I mean he didn't have his body behind the line. The winger saw this and jammed in causing the overlap. Mmmmbyeeeeee

We're so desperate for a real #13. You can't keep playing locks at 13 in the current game we just open. There's no pressure and poor old Lucy seems to cop the brunt of it.

 

[TheDaBoss]

so whats news........

 

[izotope]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

Go watch the game again. Mbye literally caused 4 of the tries through lazy careless tackles and shirt grabbing. He needs to go

No way am i watching the game again
Ill take your word for it, for the most part i saw him containing fifita pretty well

Mbye contained Fifita ?
They had to help with 3 players and caused massive numbers on the right. The sooner we wake up to this loafer the better.

Worst thing that you can have in a rebuilding team are the wrong senior players.

Probably one of Fifita's most quiet games, so Mbye and the team around contained him well.

You must not watch much footy.

For the record im all for Mbye moving on

 

[Geo]

Can anyone tell me please.
Is it after round ten or for round ten , that we can use players from our KOE team?

After..

 

[TYGA]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

Go watch the game again. Mbye literally caused 4 of the tries through lazy careless tackles and shirt grabbing. He needs to go

No way am i watching the game again
Ill take your word for it, for the most part i saw him containing fifita pretty well

Mbye contained Fifita ?
They had to help with 3 players and caused massive numbers on the right. The sooner we wake up to this loafer the better.

Worst thing that you can have in a rebuilding team are the wrong senior players.

Probably one of Fifita's most quiet games, so Mbye and the team around contained him well.

You must not watch much footy.

For the record im all for Mbye moving on

They don’t contain him at all he broke 8 tackles and ran for 150 meters. He also caused over committing and creating issues all across the defensive line which, is bad football. Fifita created havoc drawing players due to our inability to cover him. His opposing number Kelly ran for 160 metres scored and assisted on a try.

I’ve seen every game and played the game for 20 years. Mbye is a professional thief. He slides out when a player comes on the inside shoulder making it someone else’s problem. Happy to put a shot on when they run right at him. His feet point outwards any player that knows footy knows it’s an open gate, a can’t be bothered defensive stance. Leave the problem to someone else.

Brooks is guilty of this on the left as is Garner who occasionally plays hard. Luciano is a scapegoat he tries but lacks mobility as he is a man mountain. You take the good with the bad with Luch he makes up for it.

Watch the replay he is responsible for tries not only on his edge but the other. Players are smart they cover leaving the other edge exposed.

He’s got to go fast.

 

[hsvjones]

so whats news........

News is Dogs drop prized Halfback after 8.5 games but we persist with our halfback for 7 years :man-facepalming: I think we need to give Brooks a rest for a few weeks to regain confidence and give Madden a go...

Thats about the best news we can hope for as no one is signing with us in the near future.

 

[WT2K]

The POM/anyone else in the know, any updates on who we're chasing for next year?

2nd that.... we need something to look forward to as I now prefer to watch Wigan play then us.. @THE_POM

@CCTW has good info too.

The POM/anyone else in the know, any updates on who we're chasing for next year?

2nd that.... we need something to look forward to as I now prefer to watch Wigan play then us.. @THE_POM

Prefer watching our state cup team these days. @CCTW has good info too.

 

[Merlot]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

No club is paying more than 150k for Mbye. They all have televisions,
He's the "Uncle Charlie" (You've got uncle Charlie, no you've got uncle Charlie) of the NRL.

Our only hope is Hodgo doing us a solid and taking him over to Super League.

how much4 beets this week,lol

 

[dazza65]

so whats news........

News is Dogs drop prized Halfback after 8.5 games but we persist with our halfback for 7 years :man-facepalming: I think we need to give Brooks a rest for a few weeks to regain confidence and give Madden a go...

Thats about the best news we can hope for as no one is signing with us in the near future.

Been saying for weeks Brooks needs a stint in the reserves to get his mojo back...if that is even possible now...it can’t hurt at all

 

[Cairnstigers]

I think we should be going hard for Nico Hynes or Dufty now
They would both be valuable fullbacks for us
This would allow Laurie to move in the halves with Doueihi
I think that could be a lethal combination
Liddle and Simpkin can share the hooking roll until someone stands out
We should give Simpkins a go at lock to see how he goes
And we need to get Gebbie and Fitzgibbon into our team soon because we lack some serious pace
Let's face it
Could our defence be any worse

 

[tigerballs]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

Go watch the game again. Mbye literally caused 4 of the tries through lazy careless tackles and shirt grabbing. He needs to go

No way am i watching the game again
Ill take your word for it, for the most part i saw him containing fifita pretty well

Mbye contained Fifita ?
They had to help with 3 players and caused massive numbers on the right. The sooner we wake up to this loafer the better.

Worst thing that you can have in a rebuilding team are the wrong senior players.

His defence was not leader-worthy. One thing I did notice Is that people lost all faith in mbye to make his tackles. The try the Titans scored in the second half mbye had a lazy air swing. I mean he didn't have his body behind the line. The winger saw this and jammed in causing the overlap. Mmmmbyeeeeee

We're so desperate for a real #13. You can't keep playing locks at 13 in the current game we just open. There's no pressure and poor old Lucy seems to cop the brunt of it.

Joffa was one of our best.

 

[gallagher]

I know everyone on this forum is hurt after last night. But we have to look at the positives

- dead weight mostly cleared off the cap next year
- one would think mbye is gone. He lost is the game last night. I rewatched it this morning because I'm a sadist. He caused 4 of those tries in shirt grabbing and being completely out of position.
- Hastings arrives next year
- potentially 2mil to buy players. Dale finucane and a strong winger should do it
- douhei is growing every week
- bj lielua has actually improved. Guess contract years do that

Mbye is on 800-900 in 2022...the problem with his terrible form is clubs will drop off him. Who is even going to pay 400 for him at the moment?

So, we will be on the hook for 'most' of his salary even if someone is stupid enough to want him.

Can't agree with his terrible form, im really not sure why Mbye is getting flogged for last night? Is it just for the Brimson 5 on 2 overlap miss, which they are scoring no matter what? Or have i missed something else

I am sure someone will take Mbye for 400k we will be paying 50% of his freight

No club is paying more than 150k for Mbye. They all have televisions,
He's the "Uncle Charlie" (You've got uncle Charlie, no you've got uncle Charlie) of the NRL.

Our only hope is Hodgo doing us a solid and taking him over to Super League.

how much4 beets this week,lol

Black bears are the best bears, fact.

 

[watersider]

Is Tyrone Peachey off contract? He's well suited to the modern day lock position. Thought he'd be going well even before having a very good game against us.