Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[hank37w]

Well at some stage in life, nearly all females get there hands on some males sack.

Well Dennis, I have to pay that one.

 

[Tiger Stripes]

Just watched the Knights/Souths game; and in particular the effort by KPP. Because of the comments on here.
Would have been the worst forward in the Knights pack!
Why people on here want him as part of a swap/package deal is beyond me?
What did I see? Arm grabs, no tackle breaks, no side step and not fast off the mark, lazy efforts in defence unless he got in the way of the attackers, just ran as a decoy in attack.
Please, don't let this guy be our next big signing. So many better backrowers out there.
But I do have faith in Richo's and Benji's judgment of talent.

 

[Bones]

Just watched the Knights/Souths game; and in particular the effort by KPP. Because of the comments on here.
Would have been the worst forward in the Knights pack!
Why people on here want him as part of a swap/package deal is beyond me?
What did I see? Arm grabs, no tackle breaks, no side step and not fast off the mark, lazy efforts in defence unless he got in the way of the attackers, just ran as a decoy in attack.
Please, don't let this guy be our next big signing. So many better backrowers out there.
But I do have faith in Richo's and Benji's judgment of talent.

120m in attack, 2 tackle breaks, 1 line break, 38 tackles for 1 miss.

You must hate what you see from our second rowers, because neither of them are putting numbers like that let alone on a regular basis.

 

[tigertragic]

120m in attack, 2 tackle breaks, 1 line break, 38 tackles for 1 miss.

You must hate what you see from our second rowers, because neither of them are putting numbers like that let alone on a regular basis.

Unfortunately I think 30-40 mtrs was from a run when he was sitting on the wing having a rest and the ball came out to him with no one in front of him

 

[Bones]

Unfortunately I think 30-40 mtrs was from a run when he was sitting on the wing having a rest and the ball came out to him with no one in front of him

The point is he is putting up that or better every week. Meanwhile we have Seyfarth averaging 60m per game.

Is all well and good to poo poo options but you need to put it into perspective. I’d have KPP starting over Seyfarth every day of the week.

 

[Tom Shines]

You would assume the next month or so will tell us if Doueihi and/or Naden are the right players to be re-signed for our outside backs, or if we have to recruit and let them go.
We would have to find a goal kicker if we let Doueihi go.

I’ve never been too high on either of them , particularly before this year. but at the very worst, they are adequate NRL depth … we only have about 20-21 genuine NRL level players at the team, and these two are amongst them … I would be trying to keep them at this stage for another year…

I also don’t see them acquiring more than 4-5 NRL level players who are currently outside the club and based on who is still available

 

[Spartan117]

Wests Tigers Podcast Forum saying a rumour from Facebook reporting souths are chasing Seyfarth, he just extended, sounds like the usual Facebook rubbish make of it what you will.

Big Red is coming into.his best years.

I.like his interview this week where he acknowledged his level of talent vs his hard work.

 

[Camel2281]

for me , I’d go Mariner , both Mays (so all 3), KPP , Hetherington , Young .
I’d let go of Staines and maybe Naden , deepening on Value of contract for Naden .
I’d also go hard at Reynolds/ DCE with the primary objective being to be a placeholder and feed as much info into Latu Fainus head as possible . Specifically around kicking .

Based on tonight Staines has more use than Naden

 

[Winston Churchill]

What is wrong with Api Koroisau as a 1st choice goalkicker?

Hammy issues.

 

[Lestronge]

Based on tonight Staines has more use than Naden

💯

 

[Dennisspicer1]

What on earth is wrong with skelton, have we got another part time player.

 

[user118245]

At least Galvin sung the team song this week

 

[Wiz]

At least Galvin sung the team song this week

A bit half heartedly for my liking.

 

[user118245]

A bit half heartedly for my liking.

Better then nothing, wonder what it was with Staines next to him half assing it

 

[Lestronge]

What on earth is wrong with skelton, have we got another part time player.

Hamstrings are a nightmare to fix . We saw when he said he was GTG , he pulled up halfway though the match . They’ll wait now until he’s 💯 now

 

[TigerBlood93]

And I would expect similar output in the current WT environment under Benji too, assuming that he can handle the move to Sydney. His presence opens opportunities for those around him.

Sure, Fifita would be somewhat of a risk at a million dollars, but I feel some expect too much explosiveness regularly from the guy. He has not long turned 25 and I would be happy for the club to at least consider David as an option, and particularly so if available now.

For a million+ he’s getting paid, I don’t think people are expecting enough. I wouldn’t pay more than 4-500k for him. Not consistent at all. I’d be surprised if the titans let him leave unless a team covers more than 700k

 

[Telltails]

Dom Young runs one way and one way only - sideways.

Yep - and has bad hands and is a poor defender

 

[supercoach]

Yep - and has bad hands and is a poor defender

Saw a few Chook games this year where he showed very little interest in chasing a line break and at least trying to keep the try scorer to score out wide

 

[crazycat]

The point is he is putting up that or better every week. Meanwhile we have Seyfarth averaging 60m per game.

Is all well and good to poo poo options but you need to put it into perspective. I’d have KPP starting over Seyfarth every day of the week.

I don't get why Seyfarth gets such a bad rap.

Guy can cross the line, guy does his part.

Look I fully expected our forward pack to collapse. They haven't. Look we have seen May go to a next level that will likely get him picked for Origin and all kudos too him.

Seyfarth and Pole have likewise stood up. Do I want to see better starters, Yea. But I am not going to rubbish two players who have both improved their game and helped us back to 9th.

100% I am onboard with the #babygiraffefanclub

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Roosters don't seem to want Dom Young ATM
Big ,Tall ,Fast could be handy right now ?

Back to Newcastle