Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

TIGERS said:
Nothing was forced on him. I just absolutely disagree with this narrative that we took this amazing player and made him crap. He never took his own game to the next level. He just hasn't got the personality to be a top footy player. He has zero vision for what's happening in a match. Struggles to build connections with halves partners. He is just fully absorbed in his own game/performance while trying not to make mistakes.
Click to expand...
Agree to disagree.

Its like taking an IT system administrator and moving them to a building site as scaffolder, then saying they struggled to take their role to the next level... Ofcourse they are going to be worried about mistakes, they aren't comfortable doing what they are!!
 
bptiger 0 said:
That’s really no better than we have now

didnt he sign for one of the qld teams ??
Click to expand...
Have you actually seen Ethan Roberts play ?
And Just FYI
I think the bench will be;
Hayward/Hope/Latu/AD
Sione Fainu/Pole/ prop signing
Seyfarth/hunt/ which ever loser of the line above
Geyer/Roberts/Sukkar .
How anyone is saying that’s worse than this year has rocks in their heads . That’s infinitely better .
Ethan Roberts is a gun . Plays like the Butcher brothers , with a bit of Angus Chricton . He could very well be turned into a middle and be that prop .
There’s way more depth next year . KPP and Makasini will push out players like Seyfarth , Toa , Sukkar , Murray etc.
the team is way better next year even if you just simply go like for from squad players 25 and beyond . Passengers like Tumeth , Feledy and Matamua . Are now replaced by guys who can and will and have played first grade and made an impact . Roberts would have played for the chooks already if not for signing with us .
 
Tucker said:
Why are you swearing at me?
I made a simple comment not directed at you.
You have shoehorned yourself in to try and have a crack.
Dhead alright.
Click to expand...
Ooh trying to take the moral high ground. That’s a new one for you.

Gather around everybody. Look - Tucker is now the victim!

Why have you got an issue with a reporter calling it how it is? That’s you to a T.

I actually think it’s eating you up inside that you haven’t sided with him. And you’re getting more pissed off as you read this.

Mmmmm……. It really is isn’t it? Mmmmmm……
 
Wiz said:
Yep. Daily Telegraph reporting he’s been dragged into it. He was on the golf weekend. His name must have been in communications between Smith and the drug dealer.
Click to expand...
Nope. Limited details obviously as it's before the court.

His mobile was in the dealers phone.

Lets be careful here.
 
Last edited:
Tito Santana said:
Ooh trying to take the moral high ground. That’s a new one for you.

Gather around everybody. Look - Tucker is now the victim!

Why have you got an issue with a reporter calling it how it is? That’s you to a T.

I actually think it’s eating you up inside that you haven’t sided with him. And you’re getting more pissed off as you read this.

Mmmmm……. It really is isn’t it? Mmmmmm……
Click to expand...
You’re the only person I have seen side with the journo. Des had no obligation to answer the question. He made his point that retention wasn’t discussed on that platform. When the journo kept pressing, he was clearly trying to instigate fireworks to generate a story. Instead, Des just dead batted him. And totally ignored the childish dig at there being more Warriors fans. If that’s Des’ last moment as an NRL coach, it’s a good way to go out.
 
Vicious said:
Charlie Murray while not being overly big, strong or fast, he’s hard working, a good solid defender who makes nearly all of his tackles and generally has no issue getting back to marker or in the defensive line,
In his limited game time against the Cowboys he also demonstrated he can play as a 1st receiver ball playing style of 13 very comfortable and it actually created more time and soace for Luai and our left edge to function effectively.
In addition to this he can play 9 and his service from dummy half looks decent.
I’m not saying he is anything special, but he looks capable of playing roles that are required off the bench and do them effectively.
For someone outside of our top 30 I think he’s doing well, he will get an opportunity to do a full pre season with us in the lead up to 2026 and has scope to improve quite a bit because of it.
You would like to think Heath Mason being named at 14 could spend some time at 9 giving Api a rest and he offers great utility value to cover for plenty of other positions if required.
He is still only 20 years old, he will also not be considered as part of our best 17 for 2026 at the moment, but he’s known as an extremely hard worker who I’m certain will relish the challenge of improving himself to at least put himself in contention for our top 17 and I think he will relish the opportunity to impress in likely playing positions such as 9 that he has not played previously.
Sukkar is still quite young at age 21, he will have benefited from his NRL experience this seaon and while he has not set the world on fire, he has good size and mobility for a young lad and I am seeing stronger ball carries and steady all round improvement from him. Like the other two he probably will not be considered part of our initial top 17 for 2026, but he now has a good taste of NRL, so it’s up to him to have a strong off season and improve enough to at least put himself in contention.
Royce Hunt is Royce Hunt, he will give us a strong 20mins and it’s up our other 2 bench middles to provide more minutes.
I can’t see us beating the Raiders this weekend, but I can’t be blaming our bench, they are not asking to each play very minimal game time.
Click to expand...
Murray is a reserve grader, just like Sukkar. Neither have any kind of flair in attack.

The NRL is too competitive to carry these guys in first grade as we saw on the weekend.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 426 (members: 19, guests: 407)
Back
Top