Tom Amone #245

Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.
 
@mike said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337142) said:
@rihannafan1 said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337141) said:
@tyga said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337139) said:
Amone has to be in the side he has leg speed and power gets a quick play the ball for our side to get momentum. I’m impressed with Musgrove, Ofehengaue, Utoikamanu and Amone. Our front row stocks are solid we need to trade a good player like Twal, Mikalele, Tamou to get an outside back of better quality.

There’s no point having so many props and lack of talent on the edges it’s a glaring weakness. We basically will lose every game unless it rains or is a dewy night game.

In the short term could be worth putting JTJ on a wing if we want speed and Moses to the centres if things aren't working with Talau (is fine on the wing and will be a good player but JTJ is faster and better than he and Kepaoa at this stage)


JTJ is frustrated enough not getting good ball. Putting him on the wing would only magnify that frustration.

Well he won't get good ball lagging back metres behind the play with his hands on his hips, or bludging around behind the ruck. If he's frustrated then he might start by looking in the mirror for the source of his frustration.
 
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337465) said:
Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.

✅Musgrove has really put in.
❌Tamau is enjoying his Packer Pension Fund
❌ Twal offers NOTHING!..
( Just lopes around, doesn’t have an offload and has not built up over the years, preferring to maintain a ‘night club physique’ —- he should be put on the slippery dip ... then remove the stairs .. so he can’t climb back up).
 
@tonytiger said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337470) said:
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337465) said:
Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.

✅Musgrove has really put in.
❌Tamau is enjoying his Packer Pension Fund
❌ Twal offers NOTHING!..
( Just lopes around, doesn’t have an offload and has not built up over the years, preferring to maintain a ‘night club physique’ —- he should be put on the slippery dip ... then remove the stairs .. so he can’t climb back up).

Diaagree with twal

He was great lasr match
 
@thedaboss said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337482) said:
@tonytiger said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337470) said:
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337465) said:
Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.

✅Musgrove has really put in.
❌Tamau is enjoying his Packer Pension Fund
❌ Twal offers NOTHING!..
( Just lopes around, doesn’t have an offload and has not built up over the years, preferring to maintain a ‘night club physique’ —- he should be put on the slippery dip ... then remove the stairs .. so he can’t climb back up).

Diaagree with twal

He was great lasr match

He's one of our best forwards. It's hilarious that everyone complains that we can't defend and make too many errors but want to get rid of a forward who never misses tackles and rarely makes errors. Often leads in metres made too.

Teams need work horses. If Amone gets a run it will be in mikaeles spot most likely.
 
@jc99 said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337492) said:
@thedaboss said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337482) said:
@tonytiger said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337470) said:
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337465) said:
Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.

✅Musgrove has really put in.
❌Tamau is enjoying his Packer Pension Fund
❌ Twal offers NOTHING!..
( Just lopes around, doesn’t have an offload and has not built up over the years, preferring to maintain a ‘night club physique’ —- he should be put on the slippery dip ... then remove the stairs .. so he can’t climb back up).

Diaagree with twal

He was great lasr match

He's one of our best forwards. It's hilarious that everyone complains that we can't defend and make too many errors but want to get rid of a forward who never misses tackles and rarely makes errors. Often leads in metres made too.

Teams need work horses. If Amone gets a run it will be in mikaeles spot most likely.

But Twal (along with many of our forwards ) aren't dominant defenders

Getting marched back 3-4 metres with every tackle doesn't make you a good defender ....a good defender can make his 1 on 1 's ...help lead the line speed and can put the attack in 2 minds

We don't have anyone in that mould
 
@wt2k said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1335980) said:
@needaname said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1335974) said:
@tigerpower said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1331043) said:
I just watched the nsw cup game again and this guy is a machine. Has thighs bigger then half my body and runs as hard as tamouloloo. He was on another level to every forward in the game from both teams. If this is his first game back from a knee injury then wow is he going to be good.

I’m curious to know how you watched it again?
On what platform?

Kayo. Assuming fox has it too.
Highlights of the game: https://www.nswrl.com.au/news/2021/04/06/nsw-cup-highlights-magpies-v-eels-rd-4/

Thanks mate. I though you err referring to the Mounties game.
 
@jc99 said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337492) said:
Teams need work horses. If Amone gets a run it will be in mikaeles spot most likely.

That isn't right. The worst performing player should get dropped. Mikaele has been good for us.

I like Twal as well. He has been good but Mikaele has offered us more. He has at least threatened to punch through the line.
 
@tonytiger said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337470) said:
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337465) said:
Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.

✅Musgrove has really put in.
❌Tamau is enjoying his Packer Pension Fund
❌ Twal offers NOTHING!..
( Just lopes around, doesn’t have an offload and has not built up over the years, preferring to maintain a ‘night club physique’ —- he should be put on the slippery dip ... then remove the stairs .. so he can’t climb back up).

Why do you think Twal is no good? I mean I don't think he's suited to lock, but he's a good prop.
 
@mike said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337142) said:
@rihannafan1 said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337141) said:
@tyga said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337139) said:
Amone has to be in the side he has leg speed and power gets a quick play the ball for our side to get momentum. I’m impressed with Musgrove, Ofehengaue, Utoikamanu and Amone. Our front row stocks are solid we need to trade a good player like Twal, Mikalele, Tamou to get an outside back of better quality.

There’s no point having so many props and lack of talent on the edges it’s a glaring weakness. We basically will lose every game unless it rains or is a dewy night game.

In the short term could be worth putting JTJ on a wing if we want speed and Moses to the centres if things aren't working with Talau (is fine on the wing and will be a good player but JTJ is faster and better than he and Kepaoa at this stage)


JTJ is frustrated enough not getting good ball. Putting him on the wing would only magnify that frustration.

He will though get kick returns, which would give him some broken field play to work with
 
@balmain-boy said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337557) said:
@mike said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337142) said:
@rihannafan1 said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337141) said:
@tyga said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337139) said:
Amone has to be in the side he has leg speed and power gets a quick play the ball for our side to get momentum. I’m impressed with Musgrove, Ofehengaue, Utoikamanu and Amone. Our front row stocks are solid we need to trade a good player like Twal, Mikalele, Tamou to get an outside back of better quality.

There’s no point having so many props and lack of talent on the edges it’s a glaring weakness. We basically will lose every game unless it rains or is a dewy night game.

In the short term could be worth putting JTJ on a wing if we want speed and Moses to the centres if things aren't working with Talau (is fine on the wing and will be a good player but JTJ is faster and better than he and Kepaoa at this stage)


JTJ is frustrated enough not getting good ball. Putting him on the wing would only magnify that frustration.

We will though get kick returns, which would give him some broken field play to work with

Perhaps
 
@cultured_bogan said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337546) said:
@tonytiger said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337470) said:
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337465) said:
Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.

✅Musgrove has really put in.
❌Tamau is enjoying his Packer Pension Fund
❌ Twal offers NOTHING!..
( Just lopes around, doesn’t have an offload and has not built up over the years, preferring to maintain a ‘night club physique’ —- he should be put on the slippery dip ... then remove the stairs .. so he can’t climb back up).

Why do you think Twal is no good? I mean I don't think he's suited to lock, but he's a good prop.

There is the problem CB...Twal is an out and out prop,because we dont have a quality lock atm he is filling in...not brilliant in the position but honest and does his work...
 
@cultured_bogan said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337546) said:
@tonytiger said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337470) said:
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337465) said:
Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.

✅Musgrove has really put in.
❌Tamau is enjoying his Packer Pension Fund
❌ Twal offers NOTHING!..
( Just lopes around, doesn’t have an offload and has not built up over the years, preferring to maintain a ‘night club physique’ —- he should be put on the slippery dip ... then remove the stairs .. so he can’t climb back up).

Why do you think Twal is no good? I mean I don't think he's suited to lock, but he's a good prop.

Twal is statsictally efficient but just not effective. He's too slow. That's it. He doesn't miss or fall off a tackle, but his tackles aren't dominant, don't prevent offloads, and his line speed is poor. He's a solid worker in a prop rotation, but so is Tamou. They're the same player, and the current rules don't suit these sorts of players who lumber along without any energy.
 
@happy_tiger said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337504) said:
@jc99 said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337492) said:
@thedaboss said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337482) said:
@tonytiger said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337470) said:
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337465) said:
Who gets dropped to replace him. I reckon Tamou, Musgrove and Twal have been our worst performing middle forwards.

✅Musgrove has really put in.
❌Tamau is enjoying his Packer Pension Fund
❌ Twal offers NOTHING!..
( Just lopes around, doesn’t have an offload and has not built up over the years, preferring to maintain a ‘night club physique’ —- he should be put on the slippery dip ... then remove the stairs .. so he can’t climb back up).

Diaagree with twal

He was great lasr match

He's one of our best forwards. It's hilarious that everyone complains that we can't defend and make too many errors but want to get rid of a forward who never misses tackles and rarely makes errors. Often leads in metres made too.

Teams need work horses. If Amone gets a run it will be in mikaeles spot most likely.

But Twal (along with many of our forwards ) aren't dominant defenders

Getting marched back 3-4 metres with every tackle doesn't make you a good defender ....a good defender can make his 1 on 1 's ...help lead the line speed and can put the attack in 2 minds

We don't have anyone in that mould

The whole team sucks at stopping players and putting them on their back but Twal is still our best defender.
 
@earl said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337543) said:
@jc99 said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337492) said:
Teams need work horses. If Amone gets a run it will be in mikaeles spot most likely.

That isn't right. The worst performing player should get dropped. Mikaele has been good for us.

I like Twal as well. He has been good but Mikaele has offered us more. He has at least threatened to punch through the line.

He was good last game but before that he's not stood out to me, hasn't had the impact he should. If he can keep playing like he did against cowboys it's hard to drop him for sure
 
I saw the other day Armone pads his stats by being the kick off returnerer....could rack up 300m if he get a run in firsts..
 
@geo said in [Wests Tigers sign Tom Amone for 2021\.\.](/post/1337570) said:
I saw the other day Armone pads his stats by being the kick off returnerer....could rack up 300m if he get a run in firsts..


You’d think he will run a bit straighter than Nof; then again so would nan.
 
Back
Top