[2022] If Madge goes, who you have as a replacement?

I would give Madge 6 rounds to get us 3/3 , I haven’t looked at who we play I just feel he needs a time frame , if we need to change coaches this will give the new guy 3/4 of a season before we do get some quality in Api and Paps , we still need 4 players besides a coach
Tough Prop / Sims starting this year , 2 year deal
tough back rower / Defending one ( Papa to attack )
experienced fast Centre
Harris Tevita from Warriors , he’s different type 1/2 to our current
piss off , Roberts , Brooks , Kelma , Garner , Lucy , Musgrave / Joffa
Blore to come good next year after tragic season enda
New coach , and yes plenty don’t like it but
Flanno would get them cracking
asist, Rob Farrah , passion
asist , Gallen , Tough as nails
assist , part Time Cronk , Noddy was a half back and he ant teaching Brooks anything , Cronk coaching Tevita that’s the way I would go
 
426Tlgerland said:
I would give Madge 6 rounds to get us 3/3 , I haven’t looked at who we play I just feel he needs a time frame , if we need to change coaches this will give the new guy 3/4 of a season before we do get some quality in Api and Paps , we still need 4 players besides a coach
Tough Prop / Sims starting this year , 2 year deal
tough back rower / Defending one ( Papa to attack )
experienced fast Centre
Harris Tevita from Warriors , he’s different type 1/2 to our current
piss off , Roberts , Brooks , Kelma , Garner , Lucy , Musgrave / Joffa
Blore to come good next year after tragic season enda
New coach , and yes plenty don’t like it but
Flanno would get them cracking
asist, Rob Farrah , passion
asist , Gallen , Tough as nails
assist , part Time Cronk , Noddy was a half back and he ant teaching Brooks anything , Cronk coaching Tevita that’s the way I would go
Click to expand...
Can't argue mate. Alot of outside the box suggestions, but that's what might be needed. We need to take a chance at making a real change to this place and changing up the formula or we really have no future.
 
tiger_one said:
The click bait comment - ain't that true!
And a lot of your comments about past history rings true too, but I do not and cannot agree with any notion of kicking us out of the comp.
Even yesterday had moments of OK (in defense), despite the horrible stats
We can pick ourselves up and do better, but remember Sheens was only brought in late last year, the pathways is being revamped, coaching streamlines across the grades has only just started, the players are what we have for the moment - changes will come, experience will come, results will come, confidence will come.
Click to expand...
Keep dreaming!
 
Sataris said:
The issue with the club is the players.

Madge needs to sort out the playing roster. There should be no re-signings this year.

There are no players at the club worth keeping.

If we do have some kind of war-chest, as apparently we struggle to spend the entire cap (cause nobody wants to come here, which makes perfect sense).

Then madge has to be enough of a drawcard to attract real talent, and if he's not, then he what exactly is he for?
Click to expand...
Maguire already had more than enough time, and many chances to build the team the way he wanted. However, in the process we are loosing good/solid players, and too many players do not improve, and a few even go backwards. The team defence and attack did not improve. He must be held responsible for the team's mediocre performance.
 
426Tlgerland said:
I would give Madge 6 rounds to get us 3/3 , I haven’t looked at who we play I just feel he needs a time frame , if we need to change coaches this will give the new guy 3/4 of a season before we do get some quality in Api and Paps , we still need 4 players besides a coach
Tough Prop / Sims starting this year , 2 year deal
tough back rower / Defending one ( Papa to attack )
experienced fast Centre
Harris Tevita from Warriors , he’s different type 1/2 to our current
piss off , Roberts , Brooks , Kelma , Garner , Lucy , Musgrave / Joffa
Blore to come good next year after tragic season enda
New coach , and yes plenty don’t like it but
Flanno would get them cracking
asist, Rob Farrah , passion
asist , Gallen , Tough as nails
assist , part Time Cronk , Noddy was a half back and he ant teaching Brooks anything , Cronk coaching Tevita that’s the way I would go
Click to expand...
I like some of that, but especially the coaching change. Our coach, leaders, front office delivered nothing,... its the same quagmire.

Bring in some real change not the past because our past is not that great
 
tiger_one said:
And a lot of your comments about past history rings true too, but I do not and cannot agree with any notion of kicking us out of the comp.
Click to expand...

I dont know why fans even entertain this. Kick us out .... is seriously weak as a fan.

completely dont understand that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
weststigerman said:
For those who want John Morris, why were the Sharks so keen to replace him and sacrifice last season?

I have no idea if he has it or not, but seems like an odd decision for a high potential coach?
Click to expand...
Morris did well in the aftermath of the Gallen departure and the Sharks made two final series. I'd believe we may settle for one now. He was also responsible for the Pathways set up at the Sharks which has produced many good footballers.
 
Was always on the fence re Madge staying or going but surely the writing is well and truely on the wall. The players don’t play for him. We have had worse rosters and have played way better. I know a new coach might not fix the problem but getting worse and worse every year surely isn’t fixing the problem.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Morris did well in the aftermath of the Gallen departure and the Sharks made two final series. I'd believe we may settle for one now. He was also responsible for the Pathways set up at the Sharks which has produced many good footballers.
Click to expand...
I'm sure that's what he'll say if he interviews for the role. Doesn't really answer my original question though. Why move him on for another untried coach?
 
weststigerman said:
I'm sure that's what he'll say if he interviews for the role. Doesn't really answer my original question though. Why move him on for another untried coach?
Click to expand...
Back to square 1 again .will the players put in with a new coach or start another rebuild aswell
 
After reading some of the posts in this thread, it is clear to me if the best you can hope for is Farah or Morris or Flanagan (and there are some in here the really, really believe they are genuine chances), then we are in massive trouble.

Stop picking names from a hat, and getting on the train with your Lebanese favourites or your almost 1st grade quality coach, or believing the names tossed up in some BS newspaper. Put some GENUINE thought into it.
 
weststigerman said:
I'm sure that's what he'll say if he interviews for the role. Doesn't really answer my original question though. Why move him on for another untried coach?
Click to expand...
The reason u move Madge on is because nothing has changed the defence is still crap the attack is non existent, we are still playing one out hit ups , that’s why he has to go , Flanagan or Morris would be busting there bubble to get a crack as a senior coach again
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 516 (members: 3, guests: 513)
Back
Top