DonnyBrasco
New member
@Russell said:
Best thing I have read in this thread, gave me a good giggle after the disappointment.
Addo Carr signs with Storm...
- Thread starter vlad
- Start date
Best thing I have read in this thread, gave me a good giggle after the disappointment.
Chadman_s_Ghost
New member
Oh well. Move on.
People getting twisted up over this kid- geez.
Yes, he seems like there is some talent there. And maybe at Melbourne he will realise it. Maybe not. But I can tell you this- the Tigers will not fall because he left to join Melbourne.
I think the Tigers best replacement for JAC is already in the team. Kev Naquama.
I'd play Rankin or Chee Kam at centre & move Kev back onto the wing.
People getting twisted up over this kid- geez.
Yes, he seems like there is some talent there. And maybe at Melbourne he will realise it. Maybe not. But I can tell you this- the Tigers will not fall because he left to join Melbourne.
I think the Tigers best replacement for JAC is already in the team. Kev Naquama.
I'd play Rankin or Chee Kam at centre & move Kev back onto the wing.
balmain boy
Well-known member
@Chadman's Ghost said:
Problem is, Naiqama has proven time and again that he's an awful winger. Same defensive lapses, and worse than nofoaluma under the high ball. A massive no to Kevvy on the wing.
Simona or Chance Peni, or even if he's not overly fit, chuck in Karwhin
Chadman_s_Ghost
New member
@Balmain Boy said:
I don't remember Kev having anywhere near the defensive issues at wing that he does at centre.
Plus, he's a great runner from dummy half.
Yes, he has trouble under the bomb at times. But you find me a complete winger with no faults that the Tigers can afford that is off contract- and I'll be all for it.
Naiqama would get chased down by Sam Thaiday over 40m…. Quick off the mark but ridiculously slow after 30.
I think his quick hands in the Centres has been very affective.... Has set up a few tries. But then yes his defence has been average and he's let a few in also. But in saying that he has also saved a few when rushing up. Its just lately he seems to be getting caught out.
Outside of last weeks game i have been massively disappointed with Nofo this season.
I think his quick hands in the Centres has been very affective.... Has set up a few tries. But then yes his defence has been average and he's let a few in also. But in saying that he has also saved a few when rushing up. Its just lately he seems to be getting caught out.
Outside of last weeks game i have been massively disappointed with Nofo this season.
Tigertigertiger
New member
JAC wants to stay a Tiger
Apparently the two clubs are working out a deal to compensate the Storm
Fingers crossed he remains a Tiger next year
Apparently the two clubs are working out a deal to compensate the Storm
Fingers crossed he remains a Tiger next year
tsjonathan
New member
@Tigertigertiger said:
Wow, if that's true that's huge news
tig_prmz
Well-known member
oh god 53 pages AFTER he signed?
i dont get all the hype and disappointment over a kid who hasn't played much NRL.
wish him luck at the storm.
i dont get all the hype and disappointment over a kid who hasn't played much NRL.
wish him luck at the storm.
balmain boy
Well-known member
@Tigertigertiger said:
And this is based on what exactly….? What Torch said last week?
balmain boy
Well-known member
@Muffstar said:
So it's based on the Mole, based on Torch… Got it. Carry on
Tigerdave
Well-known member
isn't this done and dusted?? How much would we have to fork out to the Storm?
this is why they have to sort out the whole picking up players mid year…......really needs to be done end of the season.
this is why they have to sort out the whole picking up players mid year…......really needs to be done end of the season.
stevetiger
New member
I just read that we hadn't contacted the Storm and it wouldn't be considered if we did.
I'd love to keep him. We now have to go and find a winger to replace Rankin.
I'd love to keep him. We now have to go and find a winger to replace Rankin.
Born_tiger
Member
I saw Torch said it wold be 200k compensation to the storm…
If JAC wants to stay at the Tigers the deal should be 100k off 2017 contract and 100k off 2018 contract
I HOPE HE STAYS!!
I can't handle anymore yelling at the tv when Rankin either gets thrown out make a rubbish hit up or misses a simple goal..
If JAC wants to stay at the Tigers the deal should be 100k off 2017 contract and 100k off 2018 contract
I HOPE HE STAYS!!
I can't handle anymore yelling at the tv when Rankin either gets thrown out make a rubbish hit up or misses a simple goal..
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
@Born tiger said:
Do you rage when JAC gets dragged back 10m in tackles and doesn't compete for bombs that lead to try's?
teddy23
Well-known member
@GNR4LIFE said:
Are you trying to compare JAC with Rankin?
Everyone in this forum would be buzzing if he successfully back flipped and stayed with us, but now he's signed with Storm we look at the negatives… which is expected.
This kid has way more pros then cons!
tsjonathan
New member
JAC was always a star in NYC and stood out in first grade. He has a very bright future. Would have been a dream to keep JAC and Koriobete.
I must admit was very suprised we sign JAC.
I must admit was very suprised we sign JAC.
Blaze
Well-known member
We have had no approach from the Tigers and if they are thinking of approaching us, we won’t consider it,” Ponissi says.
“We have signed Josh and have no intention of letting him go.”
Am I missing something here?
“We have signed Josh and have no intention of letting him go.”
Am I missing something here?
Staff online
-
DempsModerator