Moses Mbye Super Duper Thread

[Demps]

He is the main reason I doubt Maguire. How any sane person could select such an absolute nuffie is above me.

Can't have an 800k player not in the team...
But yeah, he's done himself no favours with his performances and attitude.

Guy looks like his mind is elsewhere.
Talks a good talk and then turns up with zero effort performances.

Struggling to see what club would take him....

Our only hope is Brett Hodgson doing the club a favour and taking him over to Super League.
At this point the Tigers would have to kick in 600k for another NRL club to sign him.
Madge can talk him up all he likes but I'm pretty sure all the other NRL teams have televisions.

I think he wouldn't be willing to go to the UK.
Permanent beach/holiday mode, this guy.

At least Grub tried when he was on the field. This guy turns up and does the bare minimum. Embarrassment.

I don't see how he could strengthen any club... maybe the storm could see value in him? With Hynes leaving and Meany not being much chop. They love their Queenslanders. I don't know.... I just wish some one would take him off our hands...
??

I've never seen @Geo slam a player like this.
That was a highlight.

 

[Telltails]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

 

[avocadoontoast]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

 

[TrueTiger]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

 

[TigerLouis]

Mbye should be our hooker we played much better when he was there Liddle is not showing the potential he had when playing in the lower grades.& should not have been resigned. A Spine of Laurie,Douiehi,Brooks & Mbye is better more experience & leadership.

 

[avocadoontoast]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

 

[earl]

He is the main reason I doubt Maguire. How any sane person could select such an absolute nuffie is above me.

Can't have an 800k player not in the team...
But yeah, he's done himself no favours with his performances and attitude.

Guy looks like his mind is elsewhere.
Talks a good talk and then turns up with zero effort performances.

Struggling to see what club would take him....

Our only hope is Brett Hodgson doing the club a favour and taking him over to Super League.
At this point the Tigers would have to kick in 600k for another NRL club to sign him.
Madge can talk him up all he likes but I'm pretty sure all the other NRL teams have televisions.

Yeah I can’t imagine another team picking him up for more than $200k. He’s not worth more than that.

Unfortunately he’ll probably be here next year.

He is probably worth a development contract as a utility fill in player. It kills me.

 

[earl]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

He is the main reason I doubt Maguire. How any sane person could select such an absolute nuffie is above me.

Can't have an 800k player not in the team...
But yeah, he's done himself no favours with his performances and attitude.

Guy looks like his mind is elsewhere.
Talks a good talk and then turns up with zero effort performances.

Struggling to see what club would take him....

Our only hope is Brett Hodgson doing the club a favour and taking him over to Super League.
At this point the Tigers would have to kick in 600k for another NRL club to sign him.
Madge can talk him up all he likes but I'm pretty sure all the other NRL teams have televisions.

Yeah I can’t imagine another team picking him up for more than $200k. He’s not worth more than that.

Unfortunately he’ll probably be here next year.

Yeah didn't capitalise on that period where we won 3/5 and looked OK on the field. If there were any half decent offers then we should have let him walk.

 

[Geo]

He is the main reason I doubt Maguire. How any sane person could select such an absolute nuffie is above me.

Can't have an 800k player not in the team...
But yeah, he's done himself no favours with his performances and attitude.

Guy looks like his mind is elsewhere.
Talks a good talk and then turns up with zero effort performances.

Struggling to see what club would take him....

Our only hope is Brett Hodgson doing the club a favour and taking him over to Super League.
At this point the Tigers would have to kick in 600k for another NRL club to sign him.
Madge can talk him up all he likes but I'm pretty sure all the other NRL teams have televisions.

I think he wouldn't be willing to go to the UK.
Permanent beach/holiday mode, this guy.

At least Grub tried when he was on the field. This guy turns up and does the bare minimum. Embarrassment.

I don't see how he could strengthen any club... maybe the storm could see value in him? With Hynes leaving and Meany not being much chop. They love their Queenslanders. I don't know.... I just wish some one would take him off our hands...
??

I've never seen @Geo slam a player like this.
That was a highlight.

It’s been building for 2 years..

Enough is enough.. approaching Bwaith levels of disdain for this bloke in a Mighty Wests Tigers Jersey

 

[mike]

Just go..

Penny for your thoughts....? ?

My thoughts are I can't wait to see the back of the bloke..

I see comments like his service was good..well he basically passed the ball..Talau's TRY..Brooks did well to take it..made it heaps better than what it was..Nothing was created out of Dummy half when he was on the field..Liddle created our 1st TRY and had a hand in the second..

In defence he was lazy and outsmarted by Gamble ffs which lead to the Donkey's only points ..turned his back every time getting back in the defensive line..the blokes a pretender oxygen thief white ant..who for his supposed talent..is a ball shuffler at best..

You are 100% spot on there @Geo.

 

[mike]

Just go..

Penny for your thoughts....? ?

My thoughts are I can't wait to see the back of the bloke..

I see comments like his service was good..well he basically passed the ball..Talau's TRY..Brooks did well to take it..made it heaps better than what it was..Nothing was created out of Dummy half when he was on the field..Liddle created our 1st TRY and had a hand in the second..

In defence he was lazy and outsmarted by Gamble ffs which lead to the Donkey's only points ..turned his back every time getting back in the defensive line..the blokes a pretender oxygen thief white ant..who for his supposed talent..is a ball shuffler at best..

I agree 100%

Guys a passenger.
No desire or care.

Left his heart at the bulldogs.

He doesn’t have a heart.

 

[Geo]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.

Is cover code for sticking an arm out on Flegler when covering at fullback…

 

[TrueTiger]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.


Is cover code for sticking an arm out on Flegler when covering at fullback…

Yet AD,Laurie and co have been guilty of it but get passes,Mbye was very good in defense on many occasions earlier this season but now seems to be the target once again because of your dislike of him,and Madge said he did well yesterday when coming on...maybe you should be involved with WTs recruitment instead of the forum....

 

[4jtigers]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.


Is cover code for sticking an arm out on Flegler when covering at fullback…

Yet AD,Laurie and co have been guilty of it but get passes,Mbye was very good in defense on many occasions earlier this season but now seems to be the target once again because of your dislike of him,and Madge said he did well yesterday when coming on...maybe you should be involved with WTs recruitment instead of the forum....

tbh - he just doesn't care anymore... yeah he is trying but I don't see the usual Mbye playing - he is just there happy to play firstgrade

 

[earl]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.


Is cover code for sticking an arm out on Flegler when covering at fullback…

That was pathetic wasn't it. He is really a second rate player in lots of positions. I'd have no problems with him on 200k.

 

[earl]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.


Is cover code for sticking an arm out on Flegler when covering at fullback…

Yet AD,Laurie and co have been guilty of it but get passes,Mbye was very good in defense on many occasions earlier this season but now seems to be the target once again because of your dislike of him,and Madge said he did well yesterday when coming on...maybe you should be involved with WTs recruitment instead of the forum....

The thing is AD and Laurie do lots of good stuff for us. Compare their play to Mbye's yesterday. Mbye is paid more than both of them combined.

 

[TrueTiger]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.


Is cover code for sticking an arm out on Flegler when covering at fullback…

Yet AD,Laurie and co have been guilty of it but get passes,Mbye was very good in defense on many occasions earlier this season but now seems to be the target once again because of your dislike of him,and Madge said he did well yesterday when coming on...maybe you should be involved with WTs recruitment instead of the forum....

tbh - he just doesn't care anymore... yeah he is trying but I don't see the usual Mbye playing - he is just there happy to play firstgrade

I can see your point,however if he didnt do well when Madge puts him wherever he is needed and wasnt happy with his performance then he would drop him like BJ....Madge must see stuff we dont because he said yesterday that 'Moses did some good things for us'..what we see as fans is totally different what the coach sees...

 

[TrueTiger]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.


Is cover code for sticking an arm out on Flegler when covering at fullback…

Yet AD,Laurie and co have been guilty of it but get passes,Mbye was very good in defense on many occasions earlier this season but now seems to be the target once again because of your dislike of him,and Madge said he did well yesterday when coming on...maybe you should be involved with WTs recruitment instead of the forum....

The thing is AD and Laurie do lots of good stuff for us. Compare their play to Mbye's yesterday. Mbye is paid more than both of them combined.

Read my last post what Madge said about Mbye...

 

[TrueTiger]

The players all seem to love him. I just can't read him. We often play better when he is on the field yet he always looks half arsed. He must be a smooth talker because he has achieved alot in footy without delivering much.

He’s a myth for sure. I think we looked ok when he was on yesterday, but I think that probably highlighted more than anything that Liddles service isn’t where it needs to be.

And yet many have said all year that Liddle cant play 80 mins but his service and speed at dh is great for the time he is on...Mbye gets knocked and rubbished for being a utility covering a specialist job but yet there are excuses for the specialist that cant play 80mins...

I don’t think Liddles service is good. Its too slow. He tried very hard in defence but he really needs to work on his service over the off-season imo.

His service isn't that bad. It's not great though. He has a lot to work on. I think we need two hookers in the team.

I understand picking Mbye. He provides cover all over the park. You are already paying his cost.


Is cover code for sticking an arm out on Flegler when covering at fullback…

Yet AD,Laurie and co have been guilty of it but get passes,Mbye was very good in defense on many occasions earlier this season but now seems to be the target once again because of your dislike of him,and Madge said he did well yesterday when coming on...maybe you should be involved with WTs recruitment instead of the forum....

The thing is AD and Laurie do lots of good stuff for us. Compare their play to Mbye's yesterday. Mbye is paid more than both of them combined.

Also Brooks played his best footy when Mbye played alongside of him,so he obviously has something to offer otherwise Madge would have dropped him ages ago....he has dropped many and debuted many...