My team for Round 10 vs Broncos

AD is so dangerous at fullback

He has the safest pair of hands In the game , and personally I think he should be goalkicking as well

Both during souths and panthers game he made linebreaks and his lack of speed can be blames on his injury he got

:::

Spoiler Text

:::
 
@Aesopian said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180636) said:
1 - AD
2 - Nofa
3 - Talau
4 - Lawrence
5 - Tuiaki
6 - Walters
7 - Benchie
8 - Aloiai
9 - Grant
10 - Galloway
11- Ellis
12 - Lucy
13 - Twal
14 - Mikaele
15 - Eiso
16 - Garner
17 - McIntyre

A few long shots in there for sure but that's the team I want rolling out dammit!

Agree on 5 and 11, they need to be in the team.
 
@Sart0ri said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180671) said:
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180669) said:
@Telltails said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180537) said:
I don't know how any half could feel comfortable playing with Josh Reynolds. For all his enthusiasm he is totally erratic. Great energy yes but It comes at a price as all teams that have played with him have found our.

All the teams he has played with...that would be, Bulldogs, with whom made a couple of GF's, and SOO, which that year won. Oh, and Tigers.

When the Bulldogs won a grand final their forwards were actually playing as halves. In SOO most of the players have the skills of a half.

Your point is...?
 
@Telltails said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180703) said:
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180669) said:
@Telltails said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180537) said:
I don't know how any half could feel comfortable playing with Josh Reynolds. For all his enthusiasm he is totally erratic. Great energy yes but It comes at a price as all teams that have played with him have found our.

All the teams he has played with...that would be, Bulldogs, with whom made a couple of GF's, and SOO, which that year won. Oh, and Tigers.

Talking about the players around him - not clubs he has played for.

Yes, the players around him in those teams also played in GF's and won SOO. Because they were in the team with him.
 
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179844) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179791) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We will need to scout for a proper fullback won’t we !
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us .... ![alt text](image url)

@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We we’ll have to scout for one won’t we
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us

Thank you for the answer.

There is no one - so leave him at full back.

While I agree with you, Russ, I do think we need to find an alternative. I think, in some sort of order the best fullbacks are:
Teddy,
Turbo,
Ponga,
Gutho,
Papps,
Charnze,
Tuivsa-Scheck

then a gap to

Dylan Edwards
Latrell
maybe Moylan
etc etc.

I think the Manly replacement is better than AD.

Point being, a great fullback doesn't necessarily make a great team but looking at that list, the top all teams have a very good fullback. AD is a long way from that class.
 
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180801) said:
@Sart0ri said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180671) said:
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180669) said:
@Telltails said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180537) said:
I don't know how any half could feel comfortable playing with Josh Reynolds. For all his enthusiasm he is totally erratic. Great energy yes but It comes at a price as all teams that have played with him have found our.

All the teams he has played with...that would be, Bulldogs, with whom made a couple of GF's, and SOO, which that year won. Oh, and Tigers.

When the Bulldogs won a grand final their forwards were actually playing as halves. In SOO most of the players have the skills of a half.

Your point is...?

He was not playing as a 5/8, he was more of a loose forward. James Graham was 5/8 at the Bulldogs that year.
 
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180829) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179844) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179791) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We will need to scout for a proper fullback won’t we !
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us .... ![alt text](image url)

@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We we’ll have to scout for one won’t we
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us

Thank you for the answer.

There is no one - so leave him at full back.

While I agree with you, Russ, I do think we need to find an alternative. I think, in some sort of order the best fullbacks are:
Teddy,
Turbo,
Ponga,
Gutho,
Papps,
Charnze,
Tuivsa-Scheck

then a gap to

Dylan Edwards
Latrell
maybe Moylan
etc etc.

I think the Manly replacement is better than AD.

Point being, a great fullback doesn't necessarily make a great team but looking at that list, the top all teams have a very good fullback. AD is a long way from that class.

Yet shockingly, his numbers this year at fullback are every bit as good (if not better) than Charnze and RTS and not far from Ponga.
 
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179265) said:
@davey_farrell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179258) said:
of course Fifita and Staggs are due back next week against us

Turpin as well. It’ll be their strongest team in forever

If only they can find a coach in the next week
 
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180807) said:
@Telltails said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180703) said:
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180669) said:
@Telltails said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180537) said:
I don't know how any half could feel comfortable playing with Josh Reynolds. For all his enthusiasm he is totally erratic. Great energy yes but It comes at a price as all teams that have played with him have found our.

All the teams he has played with...that would be, Bulldogs, with whom made a couple of GF's, and SOO, which that year won. Oh, and Tigers.

Talking about the players around him - not clubs he has played for.

Yes, the players around him in those teams also played in GF's and won SOO. Because they were in the team with him.

Yes and all those players would of experienced his erratic play and decision making. Good teams able to absorb it much better than other teams he has played with. Unfortunately for us we do not have a team the calibre of a SOO team and JR is not the player he was in those times to compare with now.
 
@happy_tiger said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180855) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179265) said:
@davey_farrell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179258) said:
of course Fifita and Staggs are due back next week against us

Turpin as well. It’ll be their strongest team in forever

If only they can find a coach in the next week

Alex Glenn ran their training this week and they won their first game in 7 weeks, no coincidence
 
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180879) said:
@happy_tiger said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180855) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179265) said:
@davey_farrell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179258) said:
of course Fifita and Staggs are due back next week against us

Turpin as well. It’ll be their strongest team in forever

If only they can find a coach in the next week

Alex Glenn ran their training this week and they won their first game in 7 weeks, no coincidence

Then seibold had a hit taken out on him
 
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179207) said:
1 Doueihi
2 Nofa
3 Hoffman (Lawrence if Talau injured still)
4 Mbye (no other options for our back line)
5 Talau
6 Benji
7 Walters
8 Aloiai
9 Grant
10 Twal
11 Garner
12 Luciano
13 Eisenhuth
14 Mikaele
15 McIntyre
16 Clark
17 MCK (Lawrence if Talau is fit)

Good team Josh, though I’d try putting Lawrence and Talau (if fit) in the centres, move Hoffman back to the wing, piss Mbye off altogether and make Benji captain.

Is Musgrove ready to return?
 
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180879) said:
@happy_tiger said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180855) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179265) said:
@davey_farrell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179258) said:
of course Fifita and Staggs are due back next week against us

Turpin as well. It’ll be their strongest team in forever

If only they can find a coach in the next week

Alex Glenn ran their training this week and they won their first game in 7 weeks, no coincidence

No it was the Dogs .....
 
@Spud_Murphy said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180896) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179207) said:
1 Doueihi
2 Nofa
3 Hoffman (Lawrence if Talau injured still)
4 Mbye (no other options for our back line)
5 Talau
6 Benji
7 Walters
8 Aloiai
9 Grant
10 Twal
11 Garner
12 Luciano
13 Eisenhuth
14 Mikaele
15 McIntyre
16 Clark
17 MCK (Lawrence if Talau is fit)

Good team Josh, though I’d try putting Lawrence and Talau (if fit) in the centres, move Hoffman back to the wing, piss Mbye off altogether and make Benji captain.

Is Musgrove ready to return?

Musgrove might not even play again this season. Honestly I changed my mind and would play Lawrence at centre over Hoffman he did a solid job
 
@tony-soprano said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180940) said:
Same problem every year we still don’t know our best 17.

We do .. but most of them play for other clubs .
 
@avocadoontoast said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180854) said:
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180829) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179844) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179791) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We will need to scout for a proper fullback won’t we !
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us .... ![alt text](image url)

@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We we’ll have to scout for one won’t we
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us

Thank you for the answer.

There is no one - so leave him at full back.

While I agree with you, Russ, I do think we need to find an alternative. I think, in some sort of order the best fullbacks are:
Teddy,
Turbo,
Ponga,
Gutho,
Papps,
Charnze,
Tuivsa-Scheck

then a gap to

Dylan Edwards
Latrell
maybe Moylan
etc etc.

I think the Manly replacement is better than AD.

Point being, a great fullback doesn't necessarily make a great team but looking at that list, the top all teams have a very good fullback. AD is a long way from that class.

Yet shockingly, his numbers this year at fullback are every bit as good (if not better) than Charnze and RTS and not far from Ponga.

It's footy, unfortunately, not maths.
 
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180952) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180854) said:
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180829) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179844) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179791) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We will need to scout for a proper fullback won’t we !
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us .... ![alt text](image url)

@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We we’ll have to scout for one won’t we
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us

Thank you for the answer.

There is no one - so leave him at full back.

While I agree with you, Russ, I do think we need to find an alternative. I think, in some sort of order the best fullbacks are:
Teddy,
Turbo,
Ponga,
Gutho,
Papps,
Charnze,
Tuivsa-Scheck

then a gap to

Dylan Edwards
Latrell
maybe Moylan
etc etc.

I think the Manly replacement is better than AD.

Point being, a great fullback doesn't necessarily make a great team but looking at that list, the top all teams have a very good fullback. AD is a long way from that class.

Yet shockingly, his numbers this year at fullback are every bit as good (if not better) than Charnze and RTS and not far from Ponga.

It's footy, unfortunately, not maths.

Fair call, but I reckon he’s a lot better than a lot of
people give him credit for and still has a lot of upside. I might be wrong though!
 
@avocadoontoast said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180954) said:
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180952) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180854) said:
@tigerballs said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1180829) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179844) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179791) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We will need to scout for a proper fullback won’t we !
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us .... ![alt text](image url)

@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179784) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179778) said:
@JoshColeman99 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179775) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179763) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179743) said:
@hobbo1 said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179732) said:
@Russell said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179727) said:
@Hangonaminute said in [My team for Round 10 vs Broncos](/post/1179626) said:
Give Walters the no7, can't be any worse than the underachiever Brooks.

We also need a no1, Dooee isn't a bad player but he's just not a 1, adds very little in attack.
Imo he's a 3,4.
We need some speed, we need an excitement machine at the back, we've got a sloth.

Garner needs a rocket, he's nowhere near the player he was last year, gone backwards.

This is the second post I have read of yours - saying AD is not a full back and that he is too slow. Fair enough that is your opinion.

However who is the replacement, all well and good saying no but I want to know who gets the yes.

Shift Nofoaluma to the 1

Watching Doohey is like watching an old bloke in the park doing Yoga

Doohey isn’t a fullback , he’s a centre

AND Nofoaluma is not a FB. If that is the answer to our so called FB problem it is not solved.

We are talking next year here - the 2021 + seasons.

Fact ..Doohey is too slow at the back and that’s why he’s always out of position ..
He’s a centre at best .

I also don’t believe this ‘he’s always out of position’ thing. He’s saved multiple tries for us in the last few weeks, and got caught out by one kick from cleary who’s the best half in the competition right now.

Last time ..
Doohey isn’t a fullback ..never was .

He’s a fill in at best .

He’s another jack of all trades .

Why’d you think Souths let him go ?

If he was a messiah in the 1 jersey like all you lot make him out to be , Souths would’ve kept him ..

End of story

No Mate, not t he end of t he story, the start of the story.

AD is not a FB - ok that is your opinion.

I ask the question for the second or third time.

Who is his LONG TERM replacement???? It is a question, can I have an answer.

We we’ll have to scout for one won’t we
FMD ?

If Doohey is our long term fullback god help us

Thank you for the answer.

There is no one - so leave him at full back.

While I agree with you, Russ, I do think we need to find an alternative. I think, in some sort of order the best fullbacks are:
Teddy,
Turbo,
Ponga,
Gutho,
Papps,
Charnze,
Tuivsa-Scheck

then a gap to

Dylan Edwards
Latrell
maybe Moylan
etc etc.

I think the Manly replacement is better than AD.

Point being, a great fullback doesn't necessarily make a great team but looking at that list, the top all teams have a very good fullback. AD is a long way from that class.

Yet shockingly, his numbers this year at fullback are every bit as good (if not better) than Charnze and RTS and not far from Ponga.

It's footy, unfortunately, not maths.

Fair call, but I reckon he’s a lot better than a lot of
people give him credit for and still has a lot of upside. I might be wrong though!

Bloke can play footy, no doubt, I just don't think he's a fullback.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top