Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[GNR4LIFE]

Our relationship with them is already poor, this is a messy one that’s for sure…our boys think they are slick talking Galvin up trying to sell Penrith on him by saying we won’t be giving him up blah blah…it’s laughable

They can see we’re holding a pair of 2’s

 

[BAGNF05]

I don't see him beingal a more realistic option at all. You don't get a QLD kid to Sydney. Also, your money goes a lot further in Nth Qld then it does in Sydney.

Besides, he is not the type of half we need. He has very little playmaking ability. We lack points, the last thing we need is a runner, no matter how wholehearted he is. We need players that can create space for others.

You just described the bloke that just left us 😂

The final nail in the Pascoe rugby league coffin, when he plays finals at Manly next year.

 

[Jimmy]

They can see we’re holding a pair of 2’s

Doueihi=broken/Galvin=kid

We are the junk yard they are the juicy euro sports car dealership

If this were to turn around Penrith would have to be the biggest fools under the sun…Brandy and Ivan are no smarties…they are both very emotional boys however they do not like us and that passion works against us

 

[jadtiger]

They can see we’re holding a pair of 2’s

More like 2-7 offsuit with 2 Aces and a King after the flop with the man sitting next to you holding pocket Aces

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Doueihi=broken/Galvin=kid

We are the junk yard they are the juicy euro sports car dealership

If this were to turn around Penrith would have to be the biggest fools under the sun…Brandy and Ivan are no smarties…they are both very emotional boys however they do not like us and that passion works against us

The fact Cleary would do what he did to us then carry hate for us years later would be the mark of a true POS.

 

[BAGNF05]

The fact Cleary would do what he did to us then carry hate for us years later would be the mark of a true POS.

Maybe he didn’t get the support he wanted when trying to sign players like Widdop and Johnson and felt he was going to eventually be scapegoated like the rest of em’

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

I’m saying find out if you’re a rough hope before tabling a contact. If you’re not let your fan base know you had discussions but it didn’t pan out. You are unlikely to get rejected/humiliated that way.

That would make the club look even worse.

Can you imagine how the media would spin “wests tigers have spoken to 100 players and signed 3” all because we were the only ones doing that crap.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Maybe he didn’t get the support he wanted when trying to sign players like Widdop and Johnson and felt he was going to eventually be scapegoated like the rest of em’

No. He was given the cheque book. He just wanted to coach his human drive in screen for a chin son so badly, he didn’t care what the cost.

 

[Demps]

Our relationship with them is already poor, this is a messy one that’s for sure…our boys think they are slick talking Galvin up trying to sell Penrith on him by saying we won’t be giving him up blah blah…it’s laughable

$$$ talks.

We could still get Luai for 25 onwards without trading up anything.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

$$$ talks.

We could still get Luai for 25 onwards without trading up anything.

Didn’t for Moses, Mitchell or JAC

 

[Jimmy]

$$$ talks.

We could still get Luai for 25 onwards without trading up anything.

I believe our opportunity significantly decreases with a few other clubs coming into play for 2025

 

[BAGNF05]

That would make the club look even worse.

Can you imagine how the media would spin “wests tigers have spoken to 100 players and signed 3” all because we were the only ones doing that crap.

I would not suggest doing that for nuffies. We get linked to everyone anyway. As a member I wouldn’t mind hearing the truth from the club ahead of Buzz’s gossip column.

 

[Eternal Tiger]

That line is starting to get tiresome…the issues are always with the higher ups…doesn’t matter whose coach

No player doesn't not sign with a new Club because "of the higher ups" nobody will knock back an extra $1.2m over 4 years because of "the higher ups"

 

[GNR4LIFE]

He’s always been zero chance for 24. Still think the Dogs will have a big say.

 

[BAGNF05]

No player doesn't not sign with a new Club because "of the higher ups" nobody will knock back an extra $1.2m over 4 years because of "the higher ups"

They turn their back on the perceived environment, the responsibility of club hierarchy.

 

[Glenji95]

I believe our opportunity significantly decreases with a few other clubs coming into play for 2025

Who can actually sign him without having to deal with moving others on? Only us. No other club could accomodate Luai without moving talent on.

 

[Jimmy]

No player doesn't not sign with a new Club because "of the higher ups" nobody will knock back an extra $1.2m over 4 years because of "the higher ups"

I can assure you this won’t be the first time

 

[Jimmy]

Who can actually sign him without having to deal with moving others on? Only us. No other club could accomodate Luai without moving talent on.

It’s already been stated but sharks have a lot of moves going on

 

[Glenji95]

It’s already been stated but sharks have a lot of moves going on

That’s still having to move talent on to accomodate him. And given they just re-signed Toby Rudolf they made it even harder to fit Luai in.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

That’s still having to move talent on to accomodate him. And given they just re-signed Toby Rudolf they made it even harder to fit Luai in.

Someone will make room for him.