Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Tom Shines said:
If they obtain a release they will go to the market …just like May did…it doesn’t mean they are automatically signing here
Click to expand...
The same way Galvin went on the market.... He was always signing with the doggies... Parra was always a smoke screen.. Galvin actually gave it away when he did his interview with Weidler when asked that question...kid would be a horrible poker player
 
Needaname said:
correct me if I’m wrong but I think at any stage someone can be signed into NSWcup and placed on a train and trial. I think the deadline apply’s for the NRL squad only inc. supplementary players (dev deals).
Click to expand...
No idea, but if we can do that to get extra cattle in great. I agree with not just getting anyone in for a top 30 roster spot, noting some of our recent and current deadwood inhabiting the lower ends of the top 30.
 
mtd#2 said:
The same way Galvin went on the market.... He was always signing with the doggies... Parra was always a smoke screen.. Galvin actually gave it away when he did his interview with Weidler when asked that question...kid would be a horrible poker player
Click to expand...

Total different circumstances that are unique to that player involved …as was whom I mentioned May
 
Needaname said:
Out of curiosity. Say we were playing just as poorly perceived in attack but we actually got over the line against the Warriors and Rabbitohs at home. Would put us on 18 points and within a ‘hope’ of challenging for the finals but we had still suffered the last 4 defeats.
Would you and anyone else for that matter feel better about our season?
Click to expand...
Yep
 
Fish88 said:
Our biggest problem I believe is the support and resources Benji has in his stable. Employing his mates as assistants is simply not good enough. We need experienced assistant coaches.

Benji can clearly get the boys motivated, is charasmatic and has some pull in the player market.

This is the one area of the Galvin saga that I could see from Galvin's point. The coaching staff is sub par, and as a young up and coming player, you want to be coached by the best with good resources.
Click to expand...
This ☝️
Get some staff in there that are going to challenge him when needed and provide some decent winning experience to the group
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
We've actually got one of the better depth charts of juniors aged 16-20yo in most positions.

A few positions of need in pathways we could do with some external recruitment is:
  • Halves
  • Prop
Marc Tannous, Curtis Lakeman & Jhevon Lele are some progressive halves in our ranks. We also have Cohen Benson managed by Enrichd (Richo's son) so I am sure he'll be given every chance. Lele on the flip is managed by Isaac Moses.

Christian Taupau-Moors is highly rated & we have a few other 18yo & 19yo props who have powerful physical attributes such as Leviticus Tovia & Luani Tuifua. But another couple of powerhouses with good engines & leg speed wouldn't go astray especially for the Balmain squads.
Click to expand...
that gives me a little more hope thank you , how do you rate young Godinet just out of curiosity if you’ve seen some of him ? is there something there ?
 
Fish88 said:
Our biggest problem I believe is the support and resources Benji has in his stable. Employing his mates as assistants is simply not good enough. We need experienced assistant coaches.

Benji can clearly get the boys motivated, is charasmatic and has some pull in the player market.

This is the one area of the Galvin saga that I could see from Galvin's point. The coaching staff is sub par, and as a young up and coming player, you want to be coached by the best with good resources.
Click to expand...
I agree it was a poor call getting ya mates back. Not so much Morris, but then to double down with Hodgo who’s already had an average stint here was a bad look. Any young decent footballer would be looking at our coaching staff and asking why?
Benji had a good window of opportunity to get in good experienced assistants, as he basically had a guaranteed job for a few years, but the more losses he has the less time he gets, and then any new assistants bought in to help arrest the situation will be looked at as his replacements.
Still live ya Benj
 
tigahhh said:
that gives me a little more hope thank you , how do you rate young Godinet just out of curiosity if you’ve seen some of him ? is there something there ?
Click to expand...
Just provided some comments on him in the Pathways thread lol

BlackWhiteGold

Post in thread 'Juniors - Pathways General Discussion'

ancient_magpie said:
BWG what do you think of Godinets prospects please.
Click to expand...
Very exciting prospect. Dominant at Harold Matts level last year & progressed well into his bottom-age year of SG Ball, one of the best in the Magpies squad. Not overly big yet but is strong, good leg drive, nice footwork, very good defensively & has good hands, had a few try assists this year with nice balls. Has played a 4 or 5 Flegg matches off the bench (10-15 mins) this season, looked good last match in his stint. Only 18 this year has a bit of filling out to do but is very professional & diligent in his training and extras...
  • Like
 
Buttface said:
I agree it was a poor call getting ya mates back. Not so much Morris, but then to double down with Hodgo who’s already had an average stint here was a bad look. Any young decent footballer would be looking at our coaching staff and asking why?
Benji had a good window of opportunity to get in good experienced assistants, as he basically had a guaranteed job for a few years, but the more losses he has the less time he gets, and then any new assistants bought in to help arrest the situation will be looked at as his replacements.
Still live ya Benj
Click to expand...
I don't care who the assistants are ... I just want the assistants in the pre-season to remodel our attacking structures (depth, players-in-motion ... structures to put the defence in two minds every play) & defensive intent (hit hard & with purpose, not just this pussy hold stuff lol).

And I want the NSW Cup & Jersey Flegg coaches to work together as NRL transition coaches, do development plans with all individual players to help them improve & progress from Flegg to NRL, ensure these players meet KPIs inside & outside of training, bring in specialist coaches to assist their development.
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
Just provided some comments on him in the Pathways thread lol

BlackWhiteGold

Post in thread 'Juniors - Pathways General Discussion'

ancient_magpie said:
BWG what do you think of Godinets prospects please.
Click to expand...
Very exciting prospect. Dominant at Harold Matts level last year & progressed well into his bottom-age year of SG Ball, one of the best in the Magpies squad. Not overly big yet but is strong, good leg drive, nice footwork, very good defensively & has good hands, had a few try assists this year with nice balls. Has played a 4 or 5 Flegg matches off the bench (10-15 mins) this season, looked good last match in his stint. Only 18 this year has a bit of filling out to do but is very professional & diligent in his training and extras...
  • Like
Click to expand...
thanks mate , I came across his instagram randomly without seeing any of his actual game time , he does a lot of tutorials and footy videos seems really committed to his training
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
I don't care who the assistants are ... I just want the assistants in the pre-season to remodel our attacking structures (depth, players-in-motion ... structures to put the defence in two minds every play) & defensive intent (hit hard & with purpose, not just this pussy hold stuff lol).

And I want the NSW Cup & Jersey Flegg coaches to work together as NRL transition coaches, do development plans with all individual players to help them improve & progress from Flegg to NRL, ensure these players meet KPIs inside & outside of training, bring in specialist coaches to assist their development.
Click to expand...
Serious question. Does Benji have a style? Is there a trait that anyone can identify within our attacking shape that gives us the answer as to how we want to play. At the moment it seems like he is still working that out. In saying that though. The ingrained ‘Tigers way’ that you want to be rehearsed within the club through the grades kinda can limit our individual attacking strengths. I think the systematic approach to a game definitely makes sence for defence and setting a foundation but the Anthony Siebold ‘have a play for every square of the field coaching format’ can become a little frustrating for the players and can make them feel / play restricted.
 
Tom Shines said:
I don’t know how you would know now the other club’s intentions around the players being released early?
Click to expand...
I didn’t say that. I said they would have got word through management of their players intentions. They would be available November 1. Then it would be on the current club to decide if a final year at the club is worth it for them.
Anyway all speculation. A lot of clubs feel better about releasing players during the off season.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,274 (members: 26, guests: 1,248)
Back
Top